News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by mdavis6890 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:15AM (#30842800)
There is a chapter in the excellent book "Why Flip a Coin" dedicated to exploring voting alternatives. The main point of the chapter is that given three intuitively obvious requirements (like adding a 3rd candidate should not change the relative order of the first two) - it can be mathematically proven that NO voting scheme will satisfy them.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%27s_impossibility_theore...

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by dane-pgp on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:02AM (#30843481)
> adding a 3rd candidate should not change the relative order of the first two

This is, I think, the least justified requirement, since humans do naturally reframe situations when extra information is given, which can cause them to change their mind about previous decisions.

To give a trivial example, suppose you were in a district which historically had a Democrat and a Republican candidate, and you always voted Democrat, but one year a far left independent candidate became popular and you feared they would attract most Democrat voters over to their camp. Given that scenario, it might make sense for you to vote for a moderate Republican instead.

In any case, I think that the significance of Arrow's impossibility theorem is generally over-estimated (and it spreads as a meme because people like to think that all voting systems are bad so there's no reason to change the terrible one they have).

For example, the theorem only applies to ordinal (ranked) voting systems, not cardinal (rated) ones, and only proves that the system cannot output "a community-wide (complete and transitive) ranking", so it is still possible to elect a small set of politicians who collectively embody the same preferences as the voters, and in direct proportion to them.

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by wtallis on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:18AM (#30843734)
You've described an example where the addition of a third candidate causes a voter to strategically change who they're going to vote for, based on the expected outcomes under a particular voting system. That's not the same thing as the voter's actual preferences changing, it's just a manifestation of a limitation of a particular voting system.
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by couchand on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:02PM (#30848952)
What exactly do you mean by "the voter's actual preferences"?
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by twic on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:15PM (#30845503)
But all along, this person's preference is Democrat > Republican > Independent. That doesn't change. The fact that their best interests are served by casting a ballot which doesn't reflect that is exactly the problem!
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by dane-pgp on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:37AM (#30855791)
> But all along, this person's preference is Democrat > Republican > Independent.

That's a great point, thank you. I should have tried to describe a more subtle effect where someone sees the policies of the far left candidate and it taints their view of the Democrats, who they now view with suspicion, fearing the Democrats might secretly support the same extreme policies. Alternatively, a Republican voter might see the Overton window shift and consider the Democrats a more centrist party, and so drop their support for the Republicans.

The problem is, these parties (and candidates) aren't spherical cows in a vacuum, and neither are voters. Voters have imperfect information and have to try to make predictions about which politicians are lying, and what direction the mood of the country is moving; so the addition of another party into an electoral contest can quite reasonably cause someone to change how they view the existing parties and even flip their support.

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by couchand on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:11PM (#30849027)
> their best interests are served by casting a ballot which doesn't reflect that is exactly the problem!

You may be interested to hear about the Gibbard–Satterthwaite theorem then. Any non-dictatorial system with more than two alternatives is subject to tactical voting. Whoops!

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by dane-pgp on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:57AM (#30856058)
Unsurprisingly, I'm not a big fan of the Gibbard–Satterthwaite theorem either.

It does apply more broadly than Arrow's, but my understanding is that even though a tactic will exist for every voting system, that tactic may require perfect information or at least isn't guaranteed to be actually exploitable by any voters taking part.

If a tactic is so complicated and likely to backfire that no one ever attempts it (or the people that try it, on average, end up harming their cause) then I think that the threat of tactical voting is insignificant.

What I don't know, unfortunately, is which voting system is best in terms of ease of voting honestly and difficulty of voting tactically. Determining that may involve knowing things like how people respond to polling data, or to one party telling their followers to fill out their ballots in a certain way, which might be hard to model.

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by NathanielLovin on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:50AM (#30843289)
Arrow's impossibility theorem only applies to ordinal voting systems. Quadratic voting is a cardinal system. Cardinal voting still isn't perfect, but it does get around some of the problems with ordinal systems.
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by notahacker on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:26PM (#30847930)
This form of cardinal voting has a particularly egregious equivalent of the "additional candidate affects preference ordering" issue in ordinal voting systems though. Unlike the weird edge cases with preference ordering in ordinal votes, the effects of adding additional votes on reducing certain voting blocs' influence on other issues where ppeoplemust divide a budget across multiple issues often lead to intuitive (trivially simple, even) strategies to manipulate a particular outcome.

If you can add a proposition to the ballot paper which sufficiently threatens a particular group, they're forced to waste votes defending themselves against it, which means they have less influence on other issues they might also care about. As far as I can see the quadratic nature makes it worse, by making it more plausible a minority could actually lose a vote that threatens them if they only spent most of their credits defending themselves against it.

That's a bigger UX issue than non-sophisticated voters not really grasping the budgeting detail.

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by contravariant on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:36PM (#30849235)
I'm not sure quadratic voting is the best cardinal voting system though. In particular it still fails to satisfy independence of irrelevant alternatives. So sure Arrow's impossibility may not apply, but the conclusion isn't actually different.