News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by iainmerrick on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:53AM (#30841861)
If you’re willing to edit the post, I suggest just removing that whole section, or at least boiling it down to a couple of sentences (here’s a thing that went wrong, here’s the fix). It seems like a rather shallow observation that just detracts from the deeper ones that follow.
Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by timdaub on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:14AM (#30842120)
I had considered doing that.

But I think it'd paint a false picture. In the half a year of developing the app, and me being mostly concerned with correctly implementing the voting algorithm and understanding the math - when reading Wikipedia and what is outlined in Weyl's book, it wasn't obvious that fractal votes can be used.

As a single tech freelancer working for a federally-funded exhibition hall, I wanted things to be correct. So I stuck to the script (aka the most credible sources accessible).

I've added the footnote in the article linking to a Reddit post where someone claims having talked to Weyl about fractal votes and that he positively reaffirmed it [1]. Anyone could comment that though.

But from a mathematical point of view, it isn't trivial (at least for me) whether fractal votes represent the same system as is currently laid as "quadratic voting".

Sure, if I end up completely understanding why fractal votes are mathematically equal to natural-numbered votes, I'll do as you suggested.

references:

- 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/radicalxchange/comments/tprsgi/the_...

Re:The user experience problems of quadratic voting by 3np on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:03PM (#30849449)
Surely you mean fractional and not fractal?

I'm new to this but intuitively: The function is contiguous. Natural votes somehow behaving differently is what would be unexpected and need proof.