Re:Twilio employees, associates charged with insider trading...
by economist9374 on Monday March 28, 2022 @07:34PM
(#30836898)
> The auditors could potentially place bets on their engagements and negotiate results based on their interests. Impartiality would be compromised
This is a very odd straw man.
What you are describing would still be a crime in a world in which insider trading is legal.
I think you are the one who didn’t put much thought into this.
Auditors are a good example. They have privileged information and are responsible for the fairness of financial information / disclosure. Their incentives are already complicated by the compensation structure, i.e. the company they attest for pays their fee and ultimately decides whether they will work together in the future.
In this instance, an abolishment to insider trading regulation would ultimately undermine trust in the financial reporting system. The auditors could potentially place bets on their engagements and negotiate results based on their interests. Impartiality would be compromised. There are safeguards in place currently, penalties for insider trading are part of the remedy.