Re:Faster-than-light neutrinos face time trial
by pbhjpbhj on Friday October 07, 2011 @08:51AM
(#3083720)
>Contaldi pointed out what he thought it might be, OPERA is saying "we don't think that's it, here's why", not "you're wrong, our results are correct". //
I don't think that's it! [see last line].
Surely they're saying "you're wrong, that's no why our results are incorrect"?
"We don't think that's it" is just the polite version of "you're wrong" is it not. Of course one can (and should where possible) counter with "no you're wrong, here's why".
"Contaldi admits"
"Contaldi already has some company"
I wish they'd stop this. It's not a fight between the OPERA team and the world. They're not trying to get people to accept their result. This is everybody collectively trying to figure out why the data came out this way, with the expected result that there's a mistake somewhere.
Contaldi pointed out what he thought it might be, OPERA is saying "we don't think that's it, here's why", not "you're wrong, our results are correct".