Not when the state engages in deficit spending to make up for the lost income. That deficit spending will impact productivity over a very long period of time.
>>Regardless, we need to compare to the appropriate counterfactual; you're still listing a bunch of bad things that happened, but implicitly comparing those to some world where the pandemic never happened - but it did happen, so that's not valid; you need to tease out how much of those downsides are due to "lockdowns" specifically. There's just not a lot of clearcut evidence showing lockdowns actually were worse than the alternative - self-imposed lockdowns, or pre-vaccination mass outbreaks.
Obviously lockdowns increased sheltering-at-home/social-distancing behavior. If they didn't, there would have been no need to institute them.
>>Some countries suffered more; others less; but I can't see a trend (maybe somebody can, but at least a few papers on the topic are clearly biased, which doesn't help).
Here's a good meta study on the costs and benefits of lockdowns:
https://www.sfu.ca/~allen/LockdownReport.pdf
The conclusion is that the net effect of lockdowns was enormously negative.
>>Furthermore, let's talk about that word "lockdown", which you describe as being rigidly present - well, 0% of the world's countries had rigid lockdowns for the duration of the pandemic.
The definition provided in the meta-study linked above is:
>>The term “lockdown” is used to generically refer to state actions that imposed various forms of non-pharmaceutical interventions. That is, the term will be used to include mandatory state-enforced closing of non-essential business, education, recreation, and spiritual facilities; mask and social distancing orders; stay-in-place orders; and restrictions on private social gatherings.
Of course lockdowns exist on a spectrum, from most all-encompassing, to least.
>>And even that belies practical complexities - I sure get the impression that most places, for most of the duration of the pandemic did not actually police many covid-restriction-violations very harshly.
Of course, this is all very complex, but from what I've seen, the evidence suggests that the harm from non-pharmaceutical interventions that limited the right to free association and movement did massively more harm than good, even ignoring the harm to civil liberties.
>>It's perfectly plausible that a country had excellent policy, including harsh lockdowns, real lock-down related damages, and high death rates - all at once! Because the alternative might have been much worse; and _that's_ hard to measure; we can't do randomized controlled trials on entire countries.
Of course, and that is why being careful with which countries are being compared is important in trying to tease apart the effects of lockdown interventions specifically, as this analysis does:
That lockdown report makes exactly the same kind of errors your earlier reasoning did (i.e. attribute costs to lockdowns, rather than the pandemic, and ignoring possible benefits); I think the author is biased and decided not to follow the evidence, but rather to collect whatever arguments he can to arrive at his forgone conclusion. Notably, he spends lots of time trying to argue that the benefits of lockdowns were actually due to voluntary social distancing, but fails to do the same for the costs. The article smells like motivated reasoning - and given a topic that's so utterly impossible to study in isolation of course you can always find legions of reasonable sounding arguments either way. Also, the author is fairly blase in dismissing epidemiologists, which he is notably not - probably because expert opinion doesn't agree with him. And of course - if you define away the benefits to zero and assign all the costs to this account - hey, then the cost/benefit looks bad. But the devil in is the details, an that report makes no case as to why his particular way of accounting is any better than anybody else's.
I meant to leave it at that, but that paper is so bad, I can't help myself: Like, what's up with Table 2: that's a classic case is intentionally confusing correlation and causation (and it's so egregious the paper's author tries to come up with some flimsy excuse for it) - countries that have worse outbreaks will choose to have greater stringency, but of course he literally makes the argument that because this is true, lockdowns don't work. Say what? What a hack. If the author were honestly trying to tease out subtle causes and effects rather than merely ranting along his preconceived lines, he would never have included BS like that as part of his argument.
And if you google the guy - he's clearly been willing to lie with statistics before, including in a court case about same-sex marriages. This paper: same old, same old.
The lockdown report teases apart the costs of lockdowns from those of the non-lockdown-related effects of the pandemic, and also looks at the benefit of lockdowns.
I don't think you're making a genuine effort to appraise it, making it pointless for me to engage in this.
Additionally, note that it's trivial to google something like "lockdown effectiveness" in a private-mode window to escape your bubbel; and you'll see there are tons of papers arguing either case. Beyond it's technically poor analysis, it's also not representative of expert consensus; nor is the author an expert in the field, nor does he honestly portray expert opinion.
I'm not going to evaluate your claims more closely when I see very elementary mischaracterizations of the paper in your initial comments, showing you didn't make a genuine effort to appraise it.
For instance When you ascribe Fentanyl overdose deaths to lockdowns, that's a mistake. Some of those are pandemic related, sure - but not necessarily the formal lockdown bits of it. Social distancing was going to happen no matter what; as was economic disruption and huge amounts of stress - and those factors may well increase the likelihood of overdose - but they would have applies with or without lockdowns. Furthermore, the huge number of ODs existed prior to the pandemic too - https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/nchs_press_releases/2021/... - lists the year ending in April 2021 as having 28.5% more deaths than the year ending in April 2020; and fentanyl OD deaths had been rising consistently for years up to that point too, i.e. it's not reasonable to assume they wouldn't have risen even without without covid and without lockdowns. Some of that rise was due to pre-existing trends, some of it due to covid - and perhaps very little due to lockdowns; especially if the alternative to lockdowns was even more deaths and social upheaval leading to "voluntary" economic shutdown. It's perfectly plausible lockdowns caused some of those deaths; yet it's also possible they prevented yet more OD deaths too. And if Fentanyl OD's were due to lockdowns, you might expect their timing to be correlated with them, or that states with more and stronger lockdowns have higher rates - but I can't find any evidence of that - can you?
Furthermore, let's talk about that word "lockdown", which you describe as being rigidly present - well, 0% of the world's countries had rigid lockdowns for the duration of the pandemic. Some had long, very mild non-pharmaceutical interventions (including some in Sweden!). Some had occasional harsher measures, but with many long pauses in between. We might as well call these "policies", because that better represents just how diverse all these measures were, and because it doesn't prejudice the reader into thinking these measures were all particularly harsh. Is a mask-mandate for shops a lockdown? How about for public transport? How about a max-occupancy for, say, a theater? Or school closures for over 16s? How about vaccine requirements for restaurants? Or vaccine passports for large gatherings? Or non-binding work-from-home advice? ... even when in practice major firms enforce it?
And even that belies practical complexities - I sure get the impression that most places, for most of the duration of the pandemic did not actually police many covid-restriction-violations very harshly. But that too will have differed from place to place, not to mention populations differ due to culture and habits and how any given restriction interacted with other restrictions.
We can't just throw all these policies in one big huge box labelled "lockdowns", give it a good shake, and expect meaningful data to emerge: that's classic garbage in, garbage out. Some of the policies were surely more effective than others; and some more harmful. But which policies?
If that weren't bad enough; clearly various countries had waves of differing intensities at different times, largely not due to anything the government was or was not doing. And governments deal with worse situations using the tools they have - including restrictions. But that raises the question of causality, too - in places that suffered more from social distancing and more from covid, which variable caused what change in which other variable? When we see "high death rate", what we _don't_ see is how high it _would_ have been with different policies (such as no restrictions). It's perfectly plausible that a country had excellent policy, including harsh lockdowns, real lock-down related damages, and high death rates - all at once! Because the alternative might have been much worse; and _that's_ hard to measure; we can't do randomized controlled trials on entire countries.