News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The end of the nice GTK button by kaba0 on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:16AM (#30801759)
Well, you usually see the logged in user’s name and icon on the screen, and presumably you left your own computer there.

And frankly, UX is about finding the little practices that make the experience better — arbitrarily waiting for windows to bring up a prompt is not making me any good, since I know what I want to do. So in my opinion in this very special case, windows is simply doing an incorrect thing — making the common case slow.

Re:The end of the nice GTK button by d1sxeyes on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:00PM (#30803780)
> Well, you usually see the logged in user’s name and icon on the screen

I don't have this experience. On Windows (10, at least), normally I see either a black screen (if it's asleep) or a wallpaper, clock, and a message saying 'Press Ctrl + Alt + Delete to unlock.'

> arbitrarily waiting for windows to bring up a prompt

I don't think it's arbitrary. It's doing something - it's calling Winlogon, spinning up disks and reading hibernation data into memory, restarting power to powered down components, probing authentication methods available (eg: fingerprint/card readers), in case of domain joined computers, validating whether the domain is available (which means firing up network interfaces), and if so, whether the user's password has changed, etc.

There are definitely downsides to Microsoft's approach here - as you mention, in a large number of cases, it takes more time to unlock the computer.

However, there are also upsides if you accept that UX is only one consideration when designing a secure log on prompt, and there may be other priorities.