Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by Maursault on Friday March 25, 2022 @04:11AM
(#30799690)
> atheism and agnosticism are the same argument
Atheism is the belief in the absence of God. Agnosticism is an admission of lack of knowledge of God existence, neither affirmed nor denied. Thus, claiming they are the same is false equivalence.
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by orwin on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:27AM
(#30801873)
If you reason logically from an agnostic position, you are effectively atheist until proven otherwise. That's probably the correct stance, as you don't really need any gods to live your life nowadays, and pondering upon his existence, while fun, does not serve any point.
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by Maursault on Friday March 25, 2022 @09:00PM
(#30808400)
Agnosticism is not atheism, atheism is not agnosticism. The notion is absurd. False equivalence.
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by jandrewrogers on Saturday March 26, 2022 @11:29PM
(#30817476)
"I define it thus" is not an actual argument. You have made no attempt to defend your assertion.
The assertion that atheists claim to know the unknowable is baseless. We have mathematical theorems for optimally reasoning about the unknowable, the implications of which look a lot like atheism. Not following through on the implications of those theorems is willful ignorance.
I reject any argument that tries to treat agnosticism as distinct from atheism, insofar as it tacitly rejects mathematics that show their equivalence.