News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by divbzero on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @04:35PM (#30782985)
What about the alternative to ISAs proposed by OP?

Better than an ISA is an income-dependent loan with some minimum amount that must be paid back regardless of the program outcome.

With this setup:

1. You concede and comply with the existing regulation

2. You get access to the existing capital markets so financing costs come down

3. You can use credit reports as a way to enforce the contract so collection rates go up

4. Consumers already understand debt

And, most importantly, the consumer gets a better deal than a classical loan.

Similarly a bad idea relative to plain old federal loans?

Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by twblalock on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @05:29PM (#30783655)
Federal student loans already have income-based repayment options, along with forbearances and public-service loan forgiveness options.

I don't see how this proposal is a better deal.

Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by ummonk on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @11:58PM (#30786259)
It’s basically a proposal to do the same thing for private loans. Unlike the federal government, the originator of a private loan will care about repayment rates, thus somewhat aligning incentives.