News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by gruez on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:39PM (#30782411)
>First, the lack of skin in the game leads to very poor participant behavior.

is there a reason why they can't require some amount of money down (eg. a few thousand dollars), or does that go against the ISA philosophy?

Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by brimble on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:55PM (#30782572)
"A few thousand dollars" is an absolute shitload of money to most people who aren't riding the computer programming bubble, and especially young people. It may as well be $50,000 for how hard it would be for them to come up with without taking out a loan, the same way I'm not any more likely to be able to jump 20 feet in the air than I am to be able to jump to the moon.

I haven't had to count pennies at the gas pump rather than just filling it up all the way every time, or keep a running tally of what's going into my grocery cart, in many years, but I remember what it was like. $1,000 was a fuckton of money at the time. An unexpected bill for a couple hundred dollars might ruin my whole month, and maybe the next one too.

Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by cribbles on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:55PM (#30782558)
Back in 2015, when this type of thing was still novel, I participated in an ISA program that required a $3,000 deposit. It was refundable if you failed a (demonstrably) good-faith effort to applying for jobs, or rolled into the payment once you landed one.

This was a substantial amount of money for me at that time, but I probably wouldn't have applied for the program had it not been for the ISA. I was unwilling to take on new debt, and I didn't have enough money for an upfront payment. The deposit seemed like a reasonable expenditure to save toward precisely because the ISA showed that the program itself had skin-in-the-game.

Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by majormajor on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:43PM (#30782445)
Plans like these are generally intended to help precisely those people who don't have a few thousand dollars lying around. (Heck, even many traditional students taking out loans would be hard pressed to put a few thousand dollars down instead of taking out a student loan. That's a lot of money to most people in the US.)
Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by ratzkewatzke on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:42PM (#30782441)
I think that the explanation about credit scores probably applies here; much as people with good credit scores had better options than ISAs, people with some cash to put up do as well.
Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by eropple on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:41PM (#30782424)
My understanding is that a lot of the folks you'd want to target for something like this don't have appreciable funds to put down in the first place.
Re:Why income share agreements did not work out by twblalock on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @04:01PM (#30782634)
People who can put money down generally have access to other, more traditional loans (or don't need loans at all).