Re:Ask HN: Why people on HN disclaim “EDIT: ” even for the s...
by mindcrime on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @01:55PM
(#30781304)
I think all of what you say here is true, but at the same time, I don't consider it sufficient justification to have a policy of always adding an EDIT marker. The simple truth, for me, is that when you get down to really unlikely edge-cases regarding possible misunderstandings or whatever, I just don't care that much. At least not in most cases.
So I suppose you could say my policy is a sort of subjective, probability weighted policy, based on the expected probability of my edit leading to A. a misunderstanding and B. that misunderstanding being one I would care about.
The big thing is: It's hard to imagine all the ways a change can conflict with replies, and the HN crowd is probably more likely than most to "know what they don't know" (i.e. more likely to play it safe).