Re:Launch HN: Reality Defender (YC W22) – Deepfake Detection...
by rdrdg on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @08:47PM
(#30773515)
Thanks for your questions.
- The input to our models are image, video, and audio. Based on the model, we can use parts of the image (esp faces) or whole image. Yes, we also incorporate metadata for better detection.
- It's a fair concern. As quality of generative media increases, so does the sophistication of detection. Since, we fully understand how generative media is created, it gives our the leverage to reverse engg. Much like the anti-virus industry (wrt scanning), we'd need to be at the forefront of not only detection, but generation methods, re-learn models based on new generation methods, etc.
Re:Launch HN: Reality Defender (YC W22) – Deepfake Detection...
by huynhhacnguyen on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @11:07PM
(#30774421)
Thanks for the response, I'll look more into this. So what you're saying is we need to understand the methods to devise countermeasures to such methods, instead of being model-agnostic. That sounds like a grueling task and truly an arms race. Best of luck to the team!
- What do you use as input for the model? Does it use all the pixels in all the frames in the input video? How about the video's metadata (location, extension,...)?
- My biggest concern about fighting deepfakes is that they have a point to achieve where the line between reality and fiction is nonexistent. Namely, if a deepfake video of someone can be created to look exactly like a real one if that someone decide to record such a video, I imagine there would be no way to tell the deepfake video from the authentic one (since there is no difference between the two). Because of that, this looks like a losing battle to me, but maybe I'm just too pessimistic. Do you feel that it is a real problem? Do you believe it is such a long shot that we shouldn't be worried about, or even if things reach that point, there would still be tools in our arsenal to counter such technologies.