(No but seriously, rational expectations works pretty well in the limited sense of showing that economic models making other assumptions about how human behaviour expect humans to persistently make systematic errors that there's usually no justification for. It's of no value in understanding human behaviour and rather limited value in predictive modelling, especially when it emerges as the assumption that expectations are always correct in their priors, as opposed to the assumption that they eventually adapt to making random rather than systematic error. Similarly the New Keynesian paradigm is pretty good at showing that even in idealised market conditions it only takes one bit of friction to create a situation where economic stimulus results in less economic pain than letting the economy sort itself out, but if you're actually trying to predict the size of the stimulus required by estimating menu costs you're doing it wrong.
Since the New Keynesians managed to adapt their models to the Lucas critique whilst having quite different policy preferences to Lucas himself, it's also pretty clear that the allegiance to models isn't blind and economists are perfectly capable of formulating different proposals for better and for worse despite rather than because of modelling orthodoxy)
In my view, the economics academic profession is no more or less corrupt than other academics, and I can't hazard to judge the industry side beyond my own experience.
Economic policy will be made, whether we like it or not. This policy must be based on some type of model, whether that model is simple or complex. So here's the question: do you have a falsifiable, demonstrably better model than one of those used in mainstream economics? If so, you can simply show it to us. If not, then we're sticking with one of the models used in mainstream econ.
This goes for every single complaint about economics being "corrupt". Show us your better model. If you can't, well then, it doesn't matter.
We do that with a lot of nature disasters, earthquakes, volcanos, we simply don't know when they gonna happen, and build according (no buildings near volcanos, better and better buildings earthquake resistant, instead of trying to predict when and where they happen and evacuate people, that we can't).
I would be more happy if a economist said right now: "I don't know what's gonna happen, I have no idea what to do".
Than: "We should not raise minimum salary, etc, etc.." And it turns out to be wrong.
Do you perform work in exchange for money? Then you believe your currency will hold a reasonable amount of its value until you get paid, and you might believe that based on things like the currency's historical performance, etc. That is part of your economic model, and every single person who participates in the economy has a model like that. The difference in the academic discipline is that one should be precise in one's descriptions (which is what the math is for) so if they're wrong, they have no wiggle room to make ad hoc adjustments and pretend their model was actually right. So if anyone wants to criticize mainstream economic models, the real criticism should be that they aren't precise enough.
Yes, I have/use economic models in my life. The difference is I don't use them to justify changing the life of millions of people, not even my own family. I advice them, and tell them what is in my opinion in what best to do. But I always start with "I am not a financial advisor". Talking about economy now one can be 100% sure about anything.
Now change the camera to the hundreds of "economists" making predictions without any track record, without any disclamer and with 100% certains. Not just "TV"/news economists, I live in Europe, which has 27 Financial Ministers, when there is a crisis all off them always come out announcing "measures" as they know how we get out of the crisis, that none of them imagined it could happen, but knows for sure how to get out of it...
I actually don't have anything against Krugman (that actually won the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic): https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/paul-krugman-internets-eff... He never aknowledge his error, didn't even reflected why he failed this, and how to avoid it in the future, and no one asks him about it... And he is one of the "best" ones.
The news is full of this kind of "predictions" and "economic models", that are mostly wrong all the time, and then we come back and ask the same guys how to fix things now? What credibility to they have? As much as me?
Now you might think you're not applying that faulty logic here, but you really are. I don't care what some paid pundit on TV was trying to sell you; use your head.
If they would give the Nobel of Medicine to Dr. Oz, without much general commotion from other doctors: I would for sure consider Medicine a quack, or at least 90% of it, which is the one I use.
Now the questions is, are 90% of economists more close to Doctors or to astrologers?
If most of economist are quackers and I cannot distinguish them, and most of the quackers end up in Government positions and Universities: economy is quackery!
The current approach is abhorrent because of its effects on human lives today and needs to be ended for that reason. No one here is the author of the future and it's not their responsibility to present a vision of it that you will accept before you acknowledge horrors that exist now.
The onus is definitely on the persons wanting change to make an actual case for that change. So yes, it is their responsibility to present a vision of their alternative future that I will accept.
No it's not. The onus is on the people who created policies that lead to massive inequality and human misery to explain why we shouldn't string them up as an example to others.
Complaining about the status quo is extremely easy, and everyone does it. That doesn't mean they have a clue how to fix it. If you think you have a solution, prove it. Otherwise, I'll keep supporting the devil I know.
Sure don't. But I don't expect my ideas will exacerbate it.
Sounds good. Totally normal to be angry in today's environment. We disagree fundamentally. Not a lot more to be said.
Yes. My model is:
Care about full employment more.
Free trade can have benefits but without a plan it causes permanent generational harm.
Purposefully exporting your industrial base to another country will risk societal collapse.
Supply chains are fragile.
And so on. This may seem facile but it would be loads better than the current mainstream economics models. Have you actually seen any of the current models? Do you think that working up some sort of IS/LM analysis is going to lead to better outcomes? Do you think that more partial differential equations are helping somehow?
The entire fucking premise of the thing is fucked. I wrote my economics thesis on it. I don't feel like writing a long essay here but I'll tell a small story that maybe will illustrate the concept:
Ask yourself how you'd apply the concept of rational expectations or the efficient market hypothesis to the simple game of chess. Would it be a useful analysis to put two players on opposite sides of the table and say "each agent will maximize their utility and engage in actions that are understandable as rational".
I mean you could say that but what the fuck would you even mean? What is the rational next step for a participant in a game of chess? It's taken us generations of computing power to even sort of get a handle on this, and we're talking about a completely bounded game with 64 squares and 16 players on each side. Yet despite the fundamental simplicity of the system we still have a possibility space that resists analysis and is certainly not one where a normal person could optimize their strategy in any meaningful way.
But then we shift to an unbounded competitive game with billions of participants and think there's such a thing as a rational utility optimizing strategy that agents can discern and follow? GTFO. It's a nonsensical argument.
The fact is that economic systems are complex adaptive systems that display properties of chaotic behavior, non-linear responses to inputs, sensitive dependence on initial conditions, and lock-in effects.
Someone might come along and point out that actually modern economics models do take that stuff into account and there's all sorts of people working in that context, that we've handed out Nobel prizes for research on asymmetric information decision making and all that.
Cool. And yeah the people who get the premise I'm getting at, which is that neoclassical models are fucking useless at any kind of policy level, will probably be the ones that salvage economics, if in fact it's a thing that can be salvaged.
But in the meantime, I disagree with your premise. Sometimes it's better to know you don't know anything than to use your beautiful and wrong model to override people that would otherwise be making common sense decisions, like maybe we shouldn't implement austerity measures because people will die if we do.
> I mean you could say that but what the fuck would you even mean?
Strange choice of example since "rational" forward looking optimizations rather than dumb heuristics is how we get dumb silicon to play chess in a very effective (and very human-like) manner.
I get the argument that the real world is less constrained and more chaotic than chess and that lots of people suck at playing chess anyway, but rational expectations in most models isn't the assumption that every individual in the economy is always right in their predictions, it's the absence of an assumption about the types of mistake the average human must always make in response to policy changes which was explicitly or implicitly embedded in all the non ratex models. A model of chess which assumes the opponent considers the best possible moves available to them will make fewer bad mistakes than one which assumes they always take the pawn even if the opponent isn't very good and likes taking pawns.
It's perfectly possible to argue against austerity policies with a rational expectations model or without any kind of model at all, it's just better we don't make them based on models with dumber assumptions like assuming nobody will predict that austerity will leave them with less money than before.
Models which are too sensitive to the assumption people get things right are bad, but not as bad as models sensitive to the assumption they'll never adapt to stop getting things wrong in a particular way.
Not sure you actually get my argument. I could have articulated it better.
My argument is that there is no such thing as a rational strategy in something as complex and nonlinear as a global economy.
There just isn't. It's not that some participants are more or less rational. It's that you (the implicit analyst in the discussion) have no ability to define rationality at all.
The chess metaphor is to show that in chess which is profoundly simple, the idea of a rational strategy is just barely discernable at best, and only after decades of supercomputing research.
The assumption inherent in the concept of rationality in the context of economics is the argument that one has the ability to base current strategy on the ultimate outcome. But you can't.
The outcome is unknowable and the system is non-linear, often random, and resistant to cause and effect analysis to a degree that the basic premises of rational expectations and EMH type theories are useless. Or to use jargon, economic systems display emergent behavior which does not follow in an orderly fashion from initial inputs.
The only way to proceed in an environment like this is via a heuristic approach. Which, of course, is how agents in economic decisions actually formulate strategy.
The EMH/rational expectations argument implicitly states that there IS an optimal path for agents in the system, and that while it may be difficult to discern for any given participant, the sub-optimal decisions are random and cancel out leading to the system at large acting rationally.
It's bullshit. The world just doesn't work like that. And one of the reasons is that optimal strategy isn't a concept that actually exists, the system isn't orderly. The entire premise is unworkable.
It's as much a disruption of certain classical/neoclassical models as quantum physics is to classical physics. The rules work, until they don't. And when they don't what you thought you knew is worse than useless.
Anyway, epistemological agnosticism about outcomes is arguably much more compatible with the laissez-faire positions you seem to hate the most. If responses to and outcomes from public policy are unknowable, why do anything?
The classical physics analogy fits my position so perfectly I'm pretty sure I've used it before. Sure, Newton's theory of classical mechanics has no concept of subatomic particles and quarks simply don't behave like it suggests. But just because it's oversimplification at best and fundamentally wrong in other areas, and careless physics costs lives doesn't mean "caring about stuff falling down" and handwaving about complexity theory will build better bridges than the gravity-obsessed professional engineers you've confined to the cruise ship.
The academic economists are the ones that claim to be professional engineers but keep building bridges that fall down while everyone keeps screaming they have no idea what they are doing.
The Midwest‘s jobs empty out, the former Soviet Union is plunged into violence, the top 1% capture nearly all the productivity gains from the digital revolution, entire generations are unable to house themselves, pay for school, or raise children. Yet these assholes keep saying just trust me and let’s try more “free markets.”
Who’s handwaving again?
People don't listen to economists, and it's not "free markets" that are being tried. You're raging against a system where market rights have been increasingly encroached upon over the last century, as a result of politically instituted government interventions, that according to basic economics, reduce productivity growth, exacerbate income inequality, or both.
Two major examples:
1. The rapid rise of social democracy:
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-long...
Which is feeding the emergence of a highly paid cadre of government workers:
https://www.hoover.org/research/140000-year-why-are-governme...
To say nothing of the rapid expansion of the regulatory bureaucracy, and the barriers to competition it creates for major private sector incumbents, and highly paid consultants/lawyers/lobbyists who know how to navigate it.
2. The rapid increase in land-use restrictions in the major high-productivity population centers, which according to many analyses, has massively increased income inequality, while inhibiting productivity growth. E.g. this study estimates that reducing land-use restrictions in just three cities: New York, San Francisco and San Jose would increase GDP by 36.3 percent:
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/mac.20170388
This finding was echoed by the White House's Council of Economic Advisers in 2016:
https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/fi...
Although that would be the logical response to concluding that modelling public policy outcomes is impossible so government should just give up trying, which is why the Koch brothers have invested so much money in promoting that view...
That's why I specifically said a falsifiable model. The one you provide here is intentionally vague, so its shortcomings can't be critiqued.
>Do you think that working up some sort of IS/LM analysis is going to lead to better outcomes? Do you think that more partial differential equations are helping somehow?
That's a common misunderstanding of the purpose of mathematical and empirical models. The point of their precision isn't to feign perfection, it's so we can measure exactly how wrong they are for comparison; that's why they are superior to your vague model.
The models used in mainstream economics are easily disproven, which is why it's so easy to complain about them. Your model can't really be disproven or even measured at all, which places it beyond reproach. That's why I reject it. In short, you don't have a better one.
We can try things the neoclassical way and see them predict economic growth and stability and then watch the world fucking burn and inequality metastasize as a transnational global elite siphons off the resources of the masses.
Oh look, we've falsified their theory.
Now we can try mine.
This is called science.
But I'm also pointing out that this line of criticism is fucking bullshit. It's like textbook for mainstream economists to say WE HAVE THE MODELS and LOOK AT MY MODELS like they're fucking something worth bragging about. Supply, demand, regressions, Edgeworth Boley boxes, you name it one thing they are never short of is models and the smug proclamations you're making here, as a kind of generic appeal to "science" and "rigor" and so on.
Except they are wrong. Like really fucking wrong. Constantly, systematically wrong. So wrong that a lot of times the analysis is "not even wrong" levels of wrong.
I'm being specific here. I'm talking about what used to be called the "Washington Consensus" and it's one of the dumbest fucking ideas ever promulgated by supposedly smart people. Google it if you're not familiar it's well documented.
It never made sense and plenty of people pointed that out at the time and yet the 1990's were dominated by these policies and we set the stage for the world we're living in now with these catastrophically misguided ideas.
So maybe every single person responsible for that should shut the fuck up and stop talking about their fucking models. Or commit some kind of ritualistic honor driven suicide even.
Instead you have Larry Summers in the pages of the New York Times STILL somehow going on about how everyone should be listening to him. And Jason Furman. And plenty of others who should never again be allowed anywhere near a position of authority.
This is why people fucking hate economics and economists and they have VERY good reason to. Maybe one day the discipline will be reborn and redeem itself but until then I plan on staying mad.
You're illustrating my point. Making edgy rants about how everything sucks is easy, and that's why everyone does it. I can make perfectly valid complaints about economic models all day; there's really nothing to it. What's not so easy is putting forth a superior solution, and supporting that solution with evidence. I don't care how much you hate the field of economics if you can't convince me that you have something better.
A superior solution is the status quo ante.
The evidence is that neoliberal economic policies caused mass misery and instability.
The analysis isn’t particularly complicated.
Ah, the Khmer Rouge strategy. I wonder how that worked out..
It's not a coincidence that the "Nirvana fallacy" concept was coined by an economist.
Nothing I am saying diminishes that as an expression of profound evil. The question I've got though is why you're here minimizing the raw, senseless, brutal cruelty of 1990s neoliberal economic policies.
Just because you can't see pictures at the visitors center doesn't mean the misery is any less profound.
No, no reasonable person had to think about it for a second..
Kay: You know how naïve you sound? Senators and presidents don’t have men killed.
Michael: Oh. Who’s being naïve, Kay?
In other words-- you have got to make your case for Larry Summers causing more human suffering, or at least link to someone who has written that polemic.
Perhaps to improve UX there should be a 10 minute countdown to the flag being triggered. :)
First Google result: https://cepr.net/can-we-blame-larry-summers-for-the-collapse...
There's more. Lots more. It's so much worse than you think.
You're the expert. Could you give me, say, the top three articles on the subject by reputable authors? I know you say not to trust the field, but there must be an intersection between at least a few reputable writers and the subject.
It was one of several fundamentally catastrophic decisions of economic policy made in the 1990's that have their roots very firmly in academic economic orthodoxy.
If anything I'm understating how bad it was and how much needless human misery was unleashed from this community of sociopaths.
If you'd conflate between Summers' influence and the overall influence of neoliberal ideology, that's really not fair. (And full disclosure, I think this goes both ways - everything bad that happened in Cambodia cannot be ascribed to Pol Pot, but I think there's a much better argument for his having a very personalized impact on these events than there is for Summers and the collapse of the USSR.)
Dunno. Will some other neoliberal fuckhead be in charge or not?
I think you'll have trouble pressing your argument even if it is true, even if the amount of dead is 10x that just because of intent.
Dude I hate Russia, but it's not irredeemably evil. That's some cultural essentialist bullshit right there.
I have no great love for Russia and don't believe at all in the idea that the U.S. or the west in general is the source of all the misery in the world. I think it's pretty clear there are some malignant actors in the world and China and Russia are foremost among them.
But you might want to look into American post-Soviet collapse policy before you get too far over your skis.
Versus, oh I don't know, getting all scientific, and try to understand how things really are, be able to make predictions, and then maybe test one's theories. Just a thought.
Is that the kind of corruption you're talking about?
The entire modern economics profession is irredeemably corrupt and has led to unfathomable amounts of human misery due to blind allegiance to beautiful models against all obvious evidence that they had no actual relationship to how the world works. This was especially true in Microeconomics and doubly true when it comes to talking about Lucas and Sargent and the nonsense that is Rational Expectations, as well as of course EMH and other related delusions.
Our public policy would probably better served if most of the profession was put on a cruise ship and launched out to sea. Just saying.