Re:Addressing Criticism of RISC-V Microprocessors
by socialdemocrat on Sunday March 20, 2022 @02:36PM
(#30745305)
If there was some good articles to point to I would. However I don't want to single out people ranting against RISC-V. This is more about opinions which keep popping out here in Hacker news, twitter, Quora and other places. I don't want this discussion to be turned personal.
It should be possible to discuss these opinions without singling out anyone.
I am however talking about claims put forth after ARMv8. The argument here has basically been this: Both ARM and RISC-V aims to cover both the low end and high end. Some ARM fans think that by not including conditional instructions RISC-V really only works for high-end CPUs. The idea here is that AArch32 would be better than RV32 for lower-end chips.
For those following this only from the sidelines, it would help strengthen the article if the article has links to such claims. I couldn’t easily find them, and would be curious as to their age, given that, reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predication_(computer_architec..., ARM has made substantial changes to conditional execution a few times since 1994 (over 25 years ago); Thumb (1994) dropped them, Thumb-2 (2003) replaced them by, if I understand it correctly, an instruction “skip the next 4 instructions depending on flags”, and ARMv8 replaced them by conditional select.
(In general, providing links to articles claiming each proclaimed myth to be true would strengthen this article. I think I’ve only ever read about #1, and not with as strong a wording as “bloats”)