Re:Telegram is about to be blocked here in Brazil
by native_samples on Saturday March 19, 2022 @06:36AM
(#30732679)
Brazil's take is wrong, just like Russia's and China's is.
Whether something is dystopian or not is unrelated to whether it's legal. Dystopia is always legal, that's the point of it.
many things are important and all of them have in common that they find their limits within the bounds of the law. Brazil has a different take on freedom of speech than the US. You can argue about the details of this particular case of course and whether it's politized or not, but it isn't authoritarian at all to demand that tat a tech company acts within regulations. A Russian dude running a company out of Dubai by American speech standards is a nice cosmopolitan tale but has little relevance in Brazil.
>Or will you now say they shouldn't have done what they did?
Yes I think they should not have done what they did, or slightly more nuanced, if they thought it was ethical to do what they did, they should have accepted the punishment. Assange's wholesale dump in particular was damaging not just to US national security but also civilians who assisted American forces and whose identity was exposed, but that's another discussion.