News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by drekk on Friday March 18, 2022 @11:38AM (#30723618)
Or we could just... make sure people don't starve? Subsidizing corn is the worst, least direct way to do that. People don't need more high fructose corn syrup and most of that corn is going to feed or ethanol anyways.

US produces enough raw food to satiate 10 billion people. The cost is not the issue

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by kristjansson on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#30724317)
I get that you're being a bit glib, but this sort of thinking is pervasive and bothersome so I'll choose to take it seriously.

'make people not starve' is a laudable _goal_. It's a state of the work we want to reach. 'Subsidize corn farming' is a _policy_, it's an intervention that has all sorts of intended and unintended effects on the state of the world. Under that policy, fewer people starve, but also there's more HFCS, some farmers make more money than the would, some make less in inequitable ways, etc.

Regardless, if one thinks a policy isn't doing a good job achieving its intended goal, one can't just suggest achieving the goal as an alternative. If it was trivially attainable, why do we have government intervention and policies in pursuit of it?

One has to articulate an alternative policy, or at least acknowledge that an alternative is necessary. Why, after all, is it the case that the US produces as much food as it does. Is it in spite of the prevailing farm policy?

</rant>

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by colinmhayes on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:52PM (#30724570)
> One has to articulate an alternative policy

Food stamps are the best way to ensure people don't starve, not specific crop subsidies.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by chucksta on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:04PM (#30724702)
That helps feed people who can't afford food, but doesn't make food available. Subsidies are insurance for farming risk, you can't use stamps on food they didn't grow.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by colinmhayes on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:34PM (#30725090)
> but doesn't make food available

Yes it does. If people spend more money on food, food prices will go up, and more food will be grown.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by chucksta on Friday March 18, 2022 @02:48PM (#30725988)
It could make food available later. That is retroactive though, to use the stamp the food has to exist in the first place. It also doesn't relieve any risk to the farmer which is the point of the subsidy.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by DangitBobby on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:07PM (#30724738)
Cash is probably better than food stamps. Food stamps prevent you from directly buying what you actually need/want, but it doesn't prevent you from buying groceries for strangers and trading those groceries for less money so you can actually buy what you need/want. The result is that the same amount of money spent on providing assistance as food stamps doesn't provide as much benefit to the recipients as the cash equivalent. And this doesn't even include the costs of maintaining the infrastructure (including time wasted writing laws that restrict what food you can use food stamps for) required to make food stamps work.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by BitwiseFool on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:21PM (#30724164)
I wonder how much of our government's deep embrace of corn subsidies might have something to do with the fact that the Iowa Caucuses play such an outsized impact on our presidential elections. That, and how the Midwest has become more and more of a purple battleground region. I know it's not the biggest factor, but I can't help but think it has something to do with it.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by actionfromafar on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:53PM (#30724583)
I always assumed as much. Constant fear of nuclear war is not what has made the corn subsidies constant.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by jkubicek on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:00PM (#30723896)
Subsidized corn has a massive effect on decreasing food prices. People may not need high fructose corn syrup, but they need food and a lot of food has corn syrup in it. Cheaper feed leads to cheaper meat. Cheaper ethanol leads to cheaper fuel which makes everything a little less expensive.

I can't vouch for corn subsidies being the best way to lower prices, but it's certainly a powerful lever that decreases food prices across the board.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by orthecreedence on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:16PM (#30724108)
> a lot of food has corn syrup in it

Trash food.

> Cheaper feed leads to cheaper meat.

Great, don't eat meat. It's incredibly expensive, and not just monetarily.

If we're facing a food shortage, corn seems like a really bad place to dump money.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by ouid on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:56PM (#30724610)
In terms of calories per acre, corn is absolutely king. Chickens and pigs turn corn calories into meat calories at a ratio unreasonably close to 1:1, and feeding people without meat is very difficult.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by Isinlor on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:28PM (#30725022)
You have it backwards. Feeding people with meat is difficult.

This is why meat is expensive and why people in less developed countries can't afford as much meat as Americans.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by ouid on Friday March 18, 2022 @02:43PM (#30725922)
Cow meat is expensive. Chicken costs about as much as potatoes.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by lesuorac on Friday March 18, 2022 @03:43PM (#30726602)
How close do numbers need to be as much and what country?

But I also imagine it can't be cheaper to buy X food and feed it to chicken to then eat the chicken compared to just eating X food.

https://www.globalproductprices.com/Thailand/

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by kristjansson on Friday March 18, 2022 @04:21PM (#30727027)
I, for one, would much rather have chicken than chicken feed.
Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by AnimalMuppet on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:14PM (#30724075)
"Making sure people don't starve" means there has to be food. That doesn't just happen; someone has to grow it. The corn subsidy isn't about high fructose corn syrup, not really. It's fundamentally about growing more food than we need, so that, if something bad happens, we still have enough.

> US produces enough raw food to satiate 10 billion people.

I'm skeptical of that claim. Source?

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by Retric on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#30724639)
I would also like to see that estimate it seems close, but not quite enough.

“Overall production of corn in the U.S. was 15.1 billion bushels for 2021“ * 56 lb per Bushel / 10 billion people = 84.6 lb of corn per person is about 23% of the minimum calories needed per year. But corn is about 37% of all crop land.

Fishing, cattle on grassland, and hunting etc might bump that a little, but ~5 billion seems like a better theoretical estimate and presumably lower in practice.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by ben_w on Friday March 18, 2022 @11:59AM (#30723876)
The argument in favour of subsidies is not to generally reduce the cost to the consumer, it is to deliberately encourage overproduction most of the time so that even in bad years you’re still OK.

I don’t have the domain knowledge to know if this is or isn’t the reality of any actual subsidy that really exists, all I can say is that the argument seems plausible.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by yakak on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:43PM (#30724472)
Grain reserves store grain in adequate quality for at least a year so subsidizing massive overproduction doesn't make a lot of sense if a bad year is the only concern. IMO a lot of food security policy around overproduction is related to poverty, domestic hunger and international starvation in normal years.

(Driving prices down is making food a smaller percentage of the economy, making it more affordable directly to people in poverty and easier to support food programs from charity/tax.)

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by Nasrudith on Friday March 18, 2022 @03:20PM (#30726385)
Stores don't help if someone else is willing to pay more for the grain as infamously demonstrated in famines in productive regions (Irish Potato Famine and Holodomor).

Just reserves lead to speculation dynamics in shortages. There is always an expectation of the reserve running out and panics turn it self-fuffilling as infamously demonstrated by supply chain issues or possibility of snowfall. Increased production kills the expected future price.

Re:Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’... by yakak on Saturday March 19, 2022 @04:05PM (#30737095)
You seem to be talking about long term underproduction.

In the Irish case, the subsistence farmers would have been devastated by a US overproduction even before a famine, similar to subsistence farmers in Africa and India today.

Holodomor includes perpetual mismanagement and a political decision not to accept food help or really do anything. No amount of overproduction before Stalin would have prevented food being seized and then rotting in transit.

Certainly it's the case that you need at least enough overproduction to drive prices down marginally and to restock a reserve if it is actually used, and make speculation not a sure bet.. I think current subsidies go beyond that and arguably don't work because all that overproduction drove innovations in making food fungible to energy (i.e. as ethenol) and energy is now a more retainable wealth as the major input to proof of work.