News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by kragen on Thursday March 17, 2022 @06:53PM (#30716765)
Dehumidifiers aren't what's thermodynamically impossible, of course; Fontus was just making quantitative performance claims that were thermodynamically impossible about how small their system would be and how little energy it would use.

You don't need to sink to citing YouTubers to figure out how much water air contains. You can just consult a standard psychrometric chart: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:PsychrometricChart.S...

You can see from that chart that at, for example, 20 degrees and 30% relative humidity (which, if you're not aware, is pretty dry), you have about 5 mg of water per gram of air, or about 5 grams of water per kg of air, which is about 0.8 cubic meters (1.2 g/liter). So if you want to produce 10 liters of water per day for your family, you need to run 2,000 cubic meters of air through your dehumidifier. (Or a bit more because you can't reduce it to 0% humidity.)

That might sound like a lot, but it's per day, so it works out to 49 cfm, which is not "big fans and lots of power". If we're talking about a 300 mm square aperture it's 260 mm/s of airflow, a breeze you can barely feel, which requires a totally insignificant amount of power compared to the actual refrigeration involved. This is not going to fit nicely on your bicycle like in the fraudulent Fontus videos but it is entirely reasonable as a household appliance.

Solar electricity is free if you aren't using it for something else.

As for bacterial growth and filtering, yeah, that's a real design constraint, and it's one that HVAC systems have fallen down on in the past with disastrous results, but it's not some kind of unsolved engineering problem. Every air conditioner, sea voyage, and water tower deals with it. Here in Argentina just about every house has a rooftop drinking-water tank, where we control bacterial growth with chlorination, by impregnating the tank plastic with bacteriostatic agents, and by making the tanks opaque so algae can't grow. Thousands of years ago, mariners dealt with it by dropping a silver coin in each amphora of drinking water.

It would be a more difficult problem if a dehumidifier were warm and moist, but actually it's cold and moist.

As for the relative costs of tankers and electricity, well, that varies depending on where you are. Around here supply chains are so unreliable that I'd hate to rely on a weekly delivery from a water tanker in order to not die of thirst in 48 hours. (Fortunately, I live a few kilometers from the biggest river in the world. Water is not a problem here, though in places pollution is.)

Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by blkhawk on Thursday March 17, 2022 @07:20PM (#30716948)
You also need power to take the heat away that is created when the water in the air turns into a liquid. Best case you need to cool for about 0.7kwh per litre of water you make. That means for your 10 litre example you need best case 7kwh. That is a decent sized solar array and if you have any inefficiencies in your heat pump setup it gets much worse. Also you assume per day - solar only works during the day so you need storage as well so your system can work during the night.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by kragen on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:09AM (#30721723)
It's worth noting that the Nature paper abstract https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03900-w.pdf claims they're spending as little as 0.4kWh/ℓ, which is less than the 0.68kWh/ℓ of the enthalpy of vaporization, though more than the 0.34kWh/ℓ of the enthalpy of vaporization divided by the CoP of a commonplace vapor-compression heat pump. (They point out that "solar-driven cooler–condenser devices suffer from a steep loss in electric energy conversion", by which I think they mean photovoltaic panels are only about 21% efficient, so you lose 79% of your sunlight before it can start driving your compressor.) They're using a sorbent-based cycle rather than a vapor-compression cycle. I should have read this before commenting.

They cite a paper by Kim et al. that calculates the thermodynamic limits on the specific yield of atmospheric water harvesting as 5–50 ℓ/kWh (0.02–0.2 kWh/ℓ), which I suppose depends on the air temperature and humidity.

Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by kragen on Thursday March 17, 2022 @08:38PM (#30717424)
Yes, that's why I said moving the air takes "a totally insignificant amount of power compared to the actual refrigeration involved." You're talking about the actual refrigeration.

The terminology you need to google for "the heat that is created when the water in the air turns into a liquid" is "enthalpy of vaporization of water"; around room temperature this is about 2.4 MJ/kg, so 10 liters/day is 24 MJ/day, which is 6.8 kWh/day, or, in SI units, 280 watts. However, remember that a heat engine operating at the Carnot limit is reversible. The coefficient of performance of a typical heat pump at these temperatures, the kind you might buy off the shelf at a big-box hardware store, is about 2, so you only need about 12 MJ/day (3.4 kWh/day, 140 watts). At a typical desert capacity factor of 25% this means you need a 560-watt solar array, about US$120 and three square meters. (California's utility-scale PV average capacity factor was 29% last I looked.) Very cloudy and polar places can have PV capacity factors as low as 10%, but they also have easier sources of drinking water. Like a rain barrel.

It's easier to store water or to "store coldness" than to store electricity, so you don't need electrical storage, you just need a heat pump sized for your peak throughput instead of your average throughput. Heat pumps are pretty expensive, so you might think this is a big problem, but the cheapest air conditioners I can find for sale around here are about 2000 watts, not 500 watts.

I've been noodling on desiccant-powered heat pumps for this and other uses, which may be able to reduce the cost of such systems, gather a larger fraction of solar energy than the 21% of high-efficiency PV panels, and provide built-in energy storage.

Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by jodrellblank on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:30AM (#30719022)
> "You don't need to sink to citing YouTubers"

You say, whiloe going through the same calculations as Thunderf00t makes, to make the same points he makes. Including: how it is possible to do it, how dehumidifiers exist, what humidity means, how far out the Fontus design sizes were from being practically workable. 49cfm assuming you get solar power 24/7. Double or triple that to get it through while the sun is shining. I happened to see this[2] video of someone who put solar water generators on his house and reviewed it after a year. Check out from time 2:06 we can hear the fans running and see how "barely noticable" they are. (Insignificant power compared to refrigeration, I agree with). Said review video also includes a complaint about the water being unpleasantly warm to drink, because the whole system is on the roof of their house in the sun and the pipes all get warm.

> "Around here supply chains are so unreliable that I'd hate to rely on a weekly delivery from a water tanker in order to not die of thirst in 48 hours."

This comment is weird because I imagine you don't actually right now have a solar-water-dehumidifier providing water for your family so that you don't die in 48 hours when your water supply fails? If not, why not?

[2] https://youtu.be/VQRAtwz3Igs?t=126*

Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator by kragen on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:39AM (#30721405)
> You say, while going through the same calculations as Thunderf00t makes, to make the same points he makes

Right, but people reading my comment don't have to sit through a long video of some guy yelling at them to see that the calculations are correct. And they can see your correction to the airflow calculation immediately below my comment:

> Double or triple that to get it through while the sun is shining.

I'd say quadruple, given the typical 25% capacity factor for utility-scale PV in the desert in the US. (Quintuple or more if you aren't in the desert — but then you can just use a rain barrel.) I should have included that correction in my comment, and I appreciate that you took the time to point it out.

> we can hear the fans running and see how "barely noticeable" they are

It's all a matter of ducting cross-sectional area. 10k m³ per day is 120 ℓ/s; through a 100-mm-diameter round duct that's 15 meters per second, or 55 km/h, "near gale" on the Beaufort scale. The same 120 ℓ/s through a one-square-meter aperture is 120 mm/s, a wind speed where smoke from a chimney rises vertically.

> This comment is weird because I imagine you don't actually right now have a solar-water-dehumidifier providing water for your family so that you don't die in 48 hours when your water supply fails? If not, why not?

I don't live in the sort of desert where a solar dehumidifier would be a better option than a cistern; I live next to the widest river in the world. If I dig a hole in the sandy soil, after about three meters I have to stop digging unless I have an electric water pump running 24/7 to keep the hole from filling up with water. I don't know how things are where you're from, but here in Argentina, we have municipal water supplies run through pipes, supplied by water treatment plants. Unlike truckers, the pipes don't go on strike, call in sick, or get hijacked by asphalt pirates, and if a worker at the plant does, another worker can fill in for them. There's a 1000-liter water tank on the roof which takes about three days to empty when the water main does cut out. (Yes, sometimes that means it gets unpleasantly warm.) Dozens of grocery stores are a short walk away, replete with bottled water and soft drinks. We get 1200 mm of rain a year. In fact, it's raining right now.

A friend of mine lives in a nearby suburb that doesn't have a municipal water supply and where the river water is too polluted to drink safely. Her roof drains into a rain barrel.

My family members who live in semi-arid deserts without municipal water systems drill wells. (One of them actually has a dug well, the kind you could fall into, predating the municipal water supply.) The aquifers reached by the wells go lower every year, and sometimes you have to go and drill them deeper. In such places, civilizations like that of the ancestral Puebloans have collapsed during centuries of drought. People living in such places today without well-drilling equipment often spend many hours a week walking to water sources and carrying the water back home.

Many deserts today have no permanent inhabitants because of such considerations — you can only stay there until you run out of the water you brought with you. Burning Man is held in such a place, but not the driest one; there are places in the Atacama where rainfall has never been recorded. Theoretically a permanent settlement in such a place could rely on weekly water tankers driving in from wetter regions, but, for the reasons I outline above, only theoretically. Household-scale solar dehumidifiers are a much more feasible solution.

The more important reason my comment is weird is that it engages in factual and logical exploration of things that currently do not exist, but could, based on objectively verifiable information about the world. Your comment is weird in the same way, and I appreciate that. Let's have more weird comments.