Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by csours on Thursday March 17, 2022 @06:42PM
(#30716678)
I will never check out a Thunderfoot video. He is a hateful pitiful man.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by seanw444 on Thursday March 17, 2022 @06:50PM
(#30716735)
He's generally not wrong. But I agree, his approach is pretty obnoxious.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by Isamu on Thursday March 17, 2022 @08:30PM
(#30717371)
But aren’t the “debunkings” rather cursory and dismissive?
Instead I think real engineering relies on tradeoffs, certain areas of a multidimensional space where an idea makes sense - and others where it doesn’t.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by jodrellblank on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:01AM
(#30718617)
Watch them and find out? He explains why it takes so much energy to boil and condense water, calculates out and explains how many Joules to condense a litre of water, how long that would take for various solar panel sizes, compares the solar-water-collector against mains powered dehumidifiers, compares the solar collectors against using the same size panel as a rainwater catcher in different environments, compares it against the price and time to get 10,000 litres of water in a tanker and drive it a thousand kilometers, talks about the product's claimed size, isntallation cost or use cases and how they don't make sense.
I see his style is divisive, but I don't think they are cursory, at least the two I linked; he's clearly put hours of time into making them, it's not just him talking and laughing recorded in 20 minutes.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by traverseda on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:17PM
(#30724871)
This doesn't use solar electric though. It (mainly) uses direct solar heat. It also doesn't use any kind of peltier cooling. It's a largely passive device with a few minor electric components that won't draw much power.
People using his "rather cursory and dismissive" debunking to debunk other very different technology is kind of annoying.
Re:Google open sources solar atmospheric water generator
by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday March 18, 2022 @05:01AM
(#30719963)
Ok? But he’s still right.