News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on I Think Your App Should Be Free. Parent comment

Re:I Think Your App Should Be Free by sid0 on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @06:11AM (#3070189)
Since you're speaking in terms of entitlements, let's make this clear: the natural state of any idea (including large numbers such as the sequence of bits that make up an mp3) is to be free. Every human is naturally entitled through his consciousness to be able to copy and reproduce any idea he comes across.

Any restrictions imposed on them through legal or technical means are artificial and have to be justified when weighed against the costs of imposing them. For instance, protection against plagiarism has a very large benefit for not much cost so it's easily justified. For music it definitely isn't as clear-cut.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:I Think Your App Should Be Free by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @10:14PM (#3073843)
Conflating the digital representation of items with their value to society isn't any sort of logical argument. It's merely restating the problem in reductionistic terms in an attempt to sidestep the messy, moral consequences of our actions in society.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:I Think Your App Should Be Free by sid0 on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:21AM (#3075015)
I'm not reducing anything to anything. I'm saying that the default, natural, rational position is for ideas to be free, and that any deviation from that position should be sufficiently justified.
[ Parent | on HN ]