Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by smackfu on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @10:33AM
(#3071034)
Notch and company showed weakness by immediately offering concessions, so Bethesda probably figures if they push harder they will drop Scrolls entirely. Which is probably true.
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by TheCapn on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @11:16AM
(#3071254)
I'm just surprised there's no PR group talking with legal. This is a nightmare for Bethesda as Minecraft (and by extension Notch) has an extremely loyal and, dare I say, vocal following.
Win or lose Bethesda comes out looking like a evil group and probably will leave a sour taste in a few thousand gamer's mouths once it is all said and done.
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by zerostar07 on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @08:22AM
(#3070544)
Why would anyone want to make such a compromise, build a brand, make money, and then risk a lawsuit that will lead to a massive settlement. alternatives: "Scrollings", "Scrollables" etc...
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by masklinn on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @08:46AM
(#3070623)
> alternatives: "Scrollings", "Scrollables" etc...
That does not make much sense, it's not a game about scrolling it's a game about scrolls. As in rolls of parchments with words on them.
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by norova on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @11:38AM
(#3071371)
> rolls of parchments with words on them
I truly believe that Mojang could change the name to this and it would still be a smash hit.
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @08:59AM
(#3070673)
I think the point is that scrolls is a generic term describing an artefact commonly found in adventure games and so should not be seen as bearing the distinctiveness needed of a trademark to indicate the origin of goods/services in the field of computer games.
Re:Notch offered to not (tm) Scrolls etc, but Bethesda sue a...
by blackiron on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @08:54AM
(#3070663)
I don't know the game, but "papyrus" sounds like a nice alternative to me.
Bethesda/Zenimax essentially sues to prevent Mojang from using the word "Scrolls" at all, in a game which is all about, well, scrolls.