Dedicated tobacconists would probably collapse, larger stores in high-population areas may still stock tobacco products, but for the most part I would envisage smokers would be driven to specialist stores with online ordering and firm age verification.
Additionally, it would be far easier to monitor and audit the limited number of places that do stock tobacco ("secret shopper" stings and similar) to make sure they aren't being lax in their age verification.
Essentially, by making it impossible for youths simply pay someone a few bucks + the cost of the cigarettes to purchase them, the effort barrier could be made high enough as to prevent new smokers due to lack of easy availability.
That is obvious; the expression DOB > 2010 is constant for any given individual. It doesn't get any falser with time.
I don't know how rationally a 17 year old thinks about the relative difficulty of obtaining cigarettes for just a year until they turn 18, compared to having to obtain them illegally for the rest of their life, but with each passing year, the gap between {current average age of first cigarette} and {average age of smoker} will increase, making young smokers look more and more conspicuous.