I think this is a broadly fair assessment at a base level, but I hadn't considered it as such until you said it.
Most surveys done on this have shown the pesky non-spiritual to be *the* single most hated minority group in the USA. And by extension, it must at least imply that the spiritual majority are an intolerant/hateful bunch. Which certainly would tend to logically explain a lot of our history.
I do not hate non-spritual people. I am surrounded by spiritual people and can't think of any I would say this is true.
Having a faith is not irrational. As I get older I become more aware of all the great people who have gone before you and I and how short our own life will be. I am glad therefore that my view of the world does not only come from the echo chamber of my mind. Faith is one area where we can not control by ourselves. We lean on a power greater than our own understanding, which many brilliant people have done for thousands of years.
You're basically looking to rationalize the irrational. This is an exercise in futility.
Spirituality is science done upside down and backwards.
Spiritual people decide to "believe" and then seek justification and confirmation from other like minded people --- all while ignoring any contradicting info.
Group enough of these folks together into a self reinforcing feedback loop and you have a "cult".
If this could be rationalized, it would be called "science" instead of "spirituality". If "spirituality" could be reasoned with, it would cease to exist. Any such attempt is often viewed as a hostile attack on the individual's self awareness and self esteem and usually ends in rejection.