News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by ChuckMcM on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:31PM (#30678624)
Okay, I'd like to respond to this, "... you should be more scared,"

Can you reason to that position? Here is how I see it, and perhaps that will make my position more clear.

I'm going to die (so are you). Every year, the probability that I'm going to die in the next year goes up bit by bit. I don't expect to read articles that continually harp on "look how close to death you are, are you sure you don't want to eat at Cracker Barrel even ONCE before you die?"

And yet, I'm not anxious about dying. I accept that I cannot live forever and I do everything that I can do to live a long and happy life but there are things that other people do that can kill me. If Russia tosses a nuke into Silicon Valley, I'm dead, if a drunk driver crosses into my lane and crushes my car, I'm dead, if a clot in my bloodstream decides to take out a critical part of my brain, I'm dead. Nothing I can do to prevent that.

Should I be more scared of dying? How about just scared enough to do everything I can do minimize my risks? I am always open to good science that informs me and helps me make good choices about risk with respect to my mortality. I exercise, I don't smoke, I wear my seatbelt, I look both ways when I cross the street, the list goes on.

Unless you haven't been paying attention, the most recent IPCC report basically says, "We're fucked, its gonna happen now no matter what." And that sucks because in an imaginary universe where there was some sort of world government that could tell everybody on the planet what to do and enforce it if they didn't then maybe it wouldn't happen. But we don't live on that planet any more than I live on a planet that can infinitely extend my life, no matter how much I wish it.

So I point out, the planet doesn't care. Big extinction event? No big deal, been there done that, look forward to seeing what the new apex predator looks like kinda not caring.

What is even sadder, is that no credible climate scientist will say "If you do this, you'll avert disaster and it will all be well." Because we AFFECT the climate but we don't know how to CONTROL the climate. That part would require us to take actions, look at the result, and then adjust to figure out what each of the levers does and what sort of pull we might have on it.

I got into a long email discussion with one of IPCC contributors who worked on the clouds aspect of the model. Because the atmosphere is warming, it holds more moisture, and that moisture becomes clouds when you hit the dew point. Clouds can form at all levels of the atmosphere but where they form changes their impact on local weather. The cloud model shows that if we get more clouds in the stratosphere it will increase surface temperatures, if they form in the troposphere the decrease surface temperatures. It was the latter that guided the "nuclear winter" hypothesis. But we haven't gotten there yet so we don't know where they are going to start showing up (and it can be different in different parts of the world). All the science tells is that there is more energy available for things like hurricane and cyclones which are powered by the difference between surface and atmospheric temperatures, and there is more water available for things like clouds and precipitation.

You can play with the current IPCC model, change where the clouds form, and get an ice age. Pretty amazing right? But it represents the limit of our understanding in how things proceed.

But that hasn't stopped any number of groups to weaponize anxiety to encourage action on their particular idea of what's "best." Some are well meaning but others, like the nuclear industry, are really trying to convince folks that you have to start massive reactor projects right now, no matter the cost, to avert calamity. Is that accurate? No. The science says the calamity is locked and loaded. Is it effective at getting more money for nuclear? Absolutely.

"Being scared" and "being anxious" isn't productive (and it reduces your life expectancy to boot!) Being proactive about the things individuals can do is good as long as all good ideas get equal treatment, rather than pushing a single agenda (whether it is nuclear, bicycles, electric cars, or high speed rail).

That is the context of my annoyance at what I see as fear mongering headlines and articles trying to steer resources to one and only one cause.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by picometer on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @12:40AM (#30681746)
This is the headline you are annoyed at, its subheading in the article, and the article's concluding paragraph:

"Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record"

"Natural variability is probably the cause, although global warming could have a role."

“This could be the start of sustained loss of Antarctic ice similar to what we have seen in the Arctic over the past 50 years, or it could be short-term variability that reverts back to the mean year,” says Zeke Hausfather, a climate scientist at Berkeley Earth in California. In the long term, climate change will result in declining Antarctic sea ice, he adds.

I do not see fearmongering here. I see a Nature article reporting a noteworthy measurement, without applying any subjective tone or value judgement that would induce anxiety. No mention of human extinction, no mention of steering resources, no politics. In fact it emphasizes the ice's natural variability, as if the authors want to avoid fanning the flames.

Why do you see it that way? I'm actually really puzzled, since you seem to value sensible and rational consideration of things. I would've expected you to comment, "Thank goodness for a level-headed article that provides a balanced interpretation!"

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by pdonis on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:37PM (#30678700)
> the most recent IPCC report basically says, "We're fucked, its gonna happen now no matter what."

More precisely, that climate change is going to happen no matter what. Yes, that's true.

But the report does not say we cannot adapt to climate change. It only says we can't stop it from happening. We should be thinking about how to adapt--which is just the large scale equivalent of you wearing a seat belt, looking both ways before crossing the street, etc., to adapt to the fact that there are whackos out there who don't drive carefully.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:11PM (#30679109)
While you're not wrong regarding adaption, to quote a fictional chaostician:

"If there's one thing the history of evolution has taught us, it's that life will not be contained. Life breaks free, it expands to new territories, and crashes through barriers painfully, maybe even dangerously, but, uh, well, there it is."

That change is going to probably hurt a lot more than looking left or right.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by pdonis on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:17PM (#30679168)
> That change is going to probably hurt a lot more than looking left or right.

It would hurt less if we'd spent the last couple of decades thinking and talking about adaptation, and taking steps in that direction, instead of wringing our hands. Or, for that matter, if more coastal cities and nations had acted like the Netherlands, who have been managing sea level rise for more than four centuries now (an excellent example of what adaptation can accomplish), instead of like, for example, the city of Miami, which has had drainage issues for decades and has done nothing about them.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by tejohnso on Monday March 14, 2022 @08:07PM (#30680141)
> Unless you haven't been paying attention, the most recent IPCC report basically says, "We're fucked, its gonna happen now no matter what."

Yes, the IPCC is finally coming around to using the words irreversible and abrupt in their assessments.

> You can play with the current IPCC model, change where the clouds form, and get an ice age.

I don't recall seeing any mention of a potential pathway to an ice age in any IPCC report or any recent paper from a peer reviewed journal. Are you saying that there is at least one IPCC contributor who will admit that the models are so uncertain that we don't know whether to expect an ice age instead of catastrophic warming?

> weaponize anxiety to encourage action

A reasonable way to encourage action when nothing has been working. People are going even further than attempting to appeal to emotion, they're actually blocking streets and engaging in civil disobedience. That's because people still believe there's hope for themselves and / or their children and they care to attempt to push for the best outcome possible.

> "Being scared" and "being anxious" isn't productive

It absolutely can be. Sometimes you need a good amount of fear or anxiety to kick you in the ass and cause you to act. That's how most of my writing in high school got done as I didn't do anything until the panic set in. It's not ideal, but again...nothing else has been working.

> what I see as fear mongering headlines and articles trying to steer resources to one and only one cause

How many causes are as important as the preservation of habitat for homo sapiens? I don't think very many people share your "No big deal, ... look forward to seeing what the new apex predator looks like" point of view.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by zsz on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:32PM (#30681392)
I am responding to the assertion that "sometimes you need a good amount of fear or anxiety to kick you in the ass..." This supposition is not merely factually false, but is actually dangerously harmful, especially to one's mental (but also physical) health.

First, what's important to realize is, when you say it can be positive, you are thinking of incidental stressors. But that's not the case here. The sort of fear/anxiety that occurs is constant and long term, rather than incidental (e.g. worrying about something abstract, rather than fleeing from a predator). Indeed, incidental stress can be / often is productive. However, it differs fundamentally from anxiety, which is considered a mental disorder that results among others when fear / mental stress become long term / constant (such as when worrying about an abstract notion that has no direct effect on one's situational survival).

Anxiety adversely affects the amygdala and hippocampus, in particular. It causes a growth in the former, which results in intensified bodily responses to anxiety; so in that sense, it acts as a positive feedback loop that worsens the effects of anxiety as time goes on. At the same time, long term effects result in the hippocampus shrinking, which reduces a person's ability to form long term memories, or contextualize emotional responses. Needless to say, that in itself severely curtails the ability to reason on a higher level.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by tejohnso on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @08:12AM (#30684336)
This is an interesting dilemma, and I am aware that people are now seeking professional help for climate anxiety and that it can be a serious problem in some cases. However, I don't think this is a valid reason to discourage climate emergency headlines because the overall harm that is caused by our climate related activity is significantly higher than harm caused by anxiety. Without bringing serious, alarming attention to the issue, there's no way it will be addressed. I don't condone denial. But to the previous poster's point, if the situation has completely gotten away from us, then there's no point in suffering the anxiety because there's nothing to be done but await the end times. However, most people aren't on board with the hopeless abandon mindset at this time. Like so many other aspects of this problem, there's no easy solution, and it's complicated. I think the same could be said of our COVID response. Absolutely caused constant anxiety. And it was absolutely necessary. And it did encourage beneficial behaviour. The alternative is ignorance and more death.
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by pdonis on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:39PM (#30678737)
> All the science tells is that there is more energy available for things like hurricane and cyclones which are powered by the difference between surface and atmospheric temperatures

Actually, they're powered ultimately by the difference between polar and tropical temperatures, correct? A cyclone is basically just a big thing that transports energy from the tropics to the poles to equalize an imbalance. And warming affects the poles more than the tropics, so the difference between polar and tropical temperatures, and hence the energy available for cyclones, should be decreasing, not increasing.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by magicalist on Monday March 14, 2022 @08:47PM (#30680460)
> Actually, they're powered ultimately by the difference between polar and tropical temperatures, correct?

No, vast majority of energy is from warm surface waters vs temperatures up into the troposphere.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by pdonis on Monday March 14, 2022 @08:54PM (#30680527)
Once an individual cyclone gets going, that makes it stronger, yes. But what happens to cyclones? They don't just sit in the same place. They move, generally speaking, from the tropics towards the poles. That's what cyclones are doing from the perspective of the climate system as a whole, which is what the post I responded to was talking about: they're transporting energy from the tropics to the poles. (Of course they aren't the only things that do that: the overall circulation of the atmosphere does it all the time. Cyclones are just one piece of that overall picture.)
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by magicalist on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @07:42AM (#30684149)
> Once an individual cyclone gets going, that makes it stronger, yes.

No, that's what makes and maintains a cyclone. Trade winds primarily just move it.

I have no idea if trade winds are expected to fade with climate change, that's an interesting question. There will always be differentials, though, so I don't think there's reason to assume hurricanes/cyclones will stay put.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by pdonis on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @10:26AM (#30685721)
I think we're talking past each other. You're talking about individual cyclones; I'm talking about the overall effects for cyclones in general.
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by LoveGracePeace on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:39PM (#30679443)
Agreed. That was beautifully, logically stated.
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by Gravityloss on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:52AM (#30683430)
Now have time for a longer reply. There are a few different phenomena.

First is that "fear" and "anxiety" are indeed used by the news media or politicians to get more attention. There I agree. It is cheap, unsustainable and harmful. But there's more to glaciers than news fearmongering.

The second concept is "the planet doesn't care". George Carlin has his famous skit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7W33HRc1A6c Of course life will continue on earth, after relatively large temperature swings or 10 kilometer asteroid hits etc. That doesn't mean we don't need to care about anything. His skit can be seen as a wake up call (which he might or might not have meant). Why would we do anything? Why would you recycle instead of dumping plastic bags in the river? Why would you put the safety on in your gun? The planet will be fine even if you blow your leg off. But you will be affected. It's the people that are f.... That's the punchline.

But I also disagree about his "don't meddle with nature, let the species die". If we change something, let's say, dump cyanide or mercury in a river, it's not "natural" for animals to die downstream. It's not "nature doing its thing". It's our responsibility. It's an untenable philosophical position to do something and then act as if the consequences don't have anything to do with the deed. But that's not the core point of the skit.

So about caring. If there was an asteroid headed towards earth, I'd care. Yes, it's happened before, and life has survived. But I still care. It would have great negative consequences for me and others. And there are others that care. There are programs to survey asteroids. To build technology to deflect them. Why do it? The asteroids are not our fault. They have struck before. They are "natural". Sure some news media might use them as scare tactics, to get attention. Those are all red herrings. It would matter, it would cause great suffering, that could be prevented. So let's prevent it. Let's not fall into apathy.

The third is this attitude of shallow dismissal of large amounts of scientific enquiry, that was at the start of it all, in your first comment. I got the implication that the fossils show how stupid the scientists are, that everything will be fine. No, a massive amount of work has been performed studying glaciers, or climate change. We have ice penetrating radar to map the ground underneath. We track glacier flows. We measure sea temperatures at depth. Of course also paleoclimate has been studied. Paleoclimate was actually one of the great motivators for the CO2 theory, to show that climate can change drastically - more than what would be expected from the small insolation changes. If you really want to have a rational approach to glaciers, then don't follow some news talking heads but look at the science. Marine Ice Sheet Instability is the key word here.

[dead]
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by yumraj on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:44PM (#30680003)
I would argue that very few people do - especially people who have real problems today, like putting food on the table and paying rent, they don't care at all about what is going to happen next month let alone coming generation.

Now throw the religious kind in the mix, and they are either relying on divine intervention, or think humanity deserves what is coming or whatever..

And, that is the primarily the reason why this is such a difficult topic on which to get everyone on the same page.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by LoveGracePeace on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:38PM (#30679433)
That is an utter trite, passive aggressive, judgemental and potentially emotionally hurtful response to an eloquently stated position by the parent.
Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by Gravityloss on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:21PM (#30679841)
The original point was that there were flower fossils under the ice, hence we shouldn't worry.

Large sea level rise or other climate change effects can have large negative consequences. We should take a rational and responsible approach to them.

Re:Antarctic sea ice hits lowest minimum on record by ej_mage on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:30PM (#30679329)
Yes most people do :)