I don't live in my text editor. I spend most of my time in IntelliJ or Visual Studio. The conventions of normal text editors are largely established, and so something that runs counter to those normal conventions--an emacs or a vim--do get in my way. It is a mental gearshift to go "oh, I need to do something different now", which is a drain on my concentration and a way to get annoyed and off track because I tried to go Ctrl-A in Visual Studio and it didn't do what I wanted it to do. The productivity benefit of not having to make my brain go modal or instantly remap my mental keybindings to use emacs even outweighed losing the extensions I liked (vimwiki has been largely replaced by Evernote for me now).
And, yes, VS or IntelliJ are more important than my text editor. They win by default--"Well, use vim/emacs for everything!" is unacceptable for reasons that should be obvious. Vim and emacs are nonstandard at their own peril, and conforming to them is a worse use of my time than using something that conforms to expectations.
That you don't "get" how I can stand it is OK; the important thing is that I can.
I spend most of my time in IntelliJ or Visual Studio.
It's understandable then why you don't like Vim/Emacs. Yes, working with IntelliJ/Eclipse/Visual Studio is painful for me too.True anecdote - whenever I'm working with Eclipse, I have a shortcut that opens the current file in Emacs for me.
Vim and emacs are nonstandard at their own peril
I spend my time with Unix-related tools mostly, and Emacs/Vim shortcuts are not as nonstandard as you think. The Bash shell for instance uses Emacs shortcuts. In fact, all shells (like irb or ipython) powered by Readline also use Emacs shortcuts. That you don't "get" how I can stand it is OK;
the important thing is that I can.
Don't take it as a criticism on yourself; I said that mostly because I'm pretty annoyed with Textmate - it does some things really well but other (IMHO important) features are totally retarded.In other words, I can choose Vim/Emacs, slog away and get proficient, and someone else can read my code with notepad. With VCS, I'm asking casual and hardcore users to use the same UI, so it better appeal to both.
Because Emacs has some problems (it is hard to create new syntax-highlighting definitions, plugins break all the time, ELPA for package management is useless), I did try both Textmate and Sublime Text 2, several times.
But I keep going back to Emacs and personally I don't get how people can stand a text editor that doesn't even have proper UNDO (Textmate) or a text editor that doesn't have a workflow that is totally mouse-free. Emacs is also wonderful because it grows with you. Some things that should be simple are too hard indeed, but at least you can fix that.
Basically me switching to Emacs was similar to when I learned to touch-type. I did suffer, but productivity was increased tenfold in the end.
IMHO, you're not a user to require UI friendliness. The difference between a developer and a user is that users are using these applications casually. But if your day job is depending on a text editor, you should use the text editor that stays the least in your way, and friendliness has nothing to do with it. Ditto for version control.
On a side-note, race-car drivers in general do not use automatic transmissions. That's because they can change gears more efficiently than a computer can and because they don't need to eat sandwiches while driving.