Re:Electric fields, not individual neurons, may hold informa...
by grandchild on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:02AM
(#30670033)
I feel this is an overly simplistic view of depression.
I imagine there's a thousand reasons for a state like depression to emerge — some, but not all of them external. I think the Venn diagram of people with depression and people whose "lives suck for whatever reason" is not a single circle.
Re:Electric fields, not individual neurons, may hold informa...
by QuantumYeti on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:34AM
(#30670250)
> People need a better life so they don't get depressed in the first place.
You know, I think I actually agree with you on that point, despite the rest of your post. I won't address the rest of what you said, because it'd just get nasty.
The problem, in my opinion, can be described by Maslow's hierarchy of needs. In the US (probably elsewhere too, just speaking for myself), the layer below physiological needs, like clean air, shelter, clothing, etc, is: "Get a job." Without that, you're dead.
people need a better life so they don't get depressed in the first place.
"but we can't change their lives, so it's better for them to take antidepressants".
No! Nonsense!
People are depressed, because their lives suck for whatever reasons.
When they take antidepressants their lives still suck, but - like a slave! - they just learn to accept it as it is.
When you take a painkiller against pain, the pain and its source don't magically vanish. It's all still there, you just mask it out.
Are you feeling sad? Just take SOMA!