News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by rmc on Monday October 03, 2011 @12:28PM (#3066931)
Bitbucket (a popular mercurial hosting site) has added git support.

Has any popular git hosting site added mercurial support?

This shows which DVCS is winning.

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by viraptor on Monday October 03, 2011 @12:41PM (#3067001)
Alternatively it shows which group cares about getting things done, rather than some software winning/losing.
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by ergo14 on Monday October 03, 2011 @12:45PM (#3067029)
It's a power grab, and we benefit from it. There is no need for any DVCS to "win". Now you can use whatever you want without restrictions, why force others to use what you use?
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by farkas on Monday October 03, 2011 @01:01PM (#3067107)
(disclaimer - I'm the CEO of Atlassian)

Developers are religious. Whether it is vi vs emacs, or IDEA vs Eclipse or Mac vs Linux. In September we had a huge debate internally (hundreds of comments long) on functional vs non-functional programming.

We know that no-one wins in these religious debates.

We've found that developers are equally religious regarding their DVCS. Most frequently it is whatever DVCS you started with is the one that you're passionate about.

We've found that most companies of any size have both Git and Mercurial lurking somewhere in their development ranks. Previously if they wanted to host their code in the cloud (and who wouldn't), they would have had to choose two different hosting providers. As a developer, this was a pain as you never knew where your code was.

Now that Bitbucket supports both, you no longer have to choose. We think this is a huge win! Companies can store all their code in one place. And with the per-user pricing, it is a very fair pricing model (don't have to think about whether a fork is going to cost you or not!).

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by pixeloution on Monday October 03, 2011 @01:26PM (#3067198)
If we had to re-make the decision of what remote DVCS host to use, I'd certainly look strongly at bitbucket. We have only a small handful of developers, but many repositories (60+) all getting low traffic.

We've used both Github and Beanstalkapp.com and both charge based on total repos rather then disk space or developers which, frankly, drives me a bit insane. I think both have better features then bitbucket (as far as I am aware) and better UI's (subjective) but my 60 small repos run me $100/month at beanstalk - not sure what it would run @ github.

I can't find any disk usage limits @ BB's site, which makes me wonder if there are hidden caps. If BB ever struck me as being as slick as github, I'd move our business in a second, even if the cost was higher then it is now ($10 a month? Really?!).

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by farkas on Monday October 03, 2011 @02:27PM (#3067386)
Just as a FYI - we don't have any disk limits (apart from fair use).

We don't want our pricing to be based on repos, or disk space, or any other limitation that is hard to predict, or encourages sub-optimal decision making to optimise cost. We think that users is the best way to price a product, and is easy to predict.

In terms of UI - there are things that bug me today, but our team is cranking along improving it.

But we have found that most of our users spend their time interacting via the command-line, and therefore we have prioritised features around stability and performance, as well as enabling Git support. Now that this is done, we'll be focusing more time on UI again.

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by danieldk on Monday October 03, 2011 @03:22PM (#3067598)
Just as a FYI - we don't have any disk limits (apart from fair use).

Let me ask you about a particular case then :). I am in a group that develops a natural language parser for Dutch. It's open source, but so far we have been hosting it in a private Subversion repository on our university servers. We do provide a read-only (somewhat hidden) git mirror of the tree, but we have considered publishing it as an public git repository, but were always worried that the repository is too large for hosting it externally.

The git repository has existed for one and a half year, and the bare repo is currently 1098 MB in size*. Would hosting such a repository on Bitbucket be considered fair-use?

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by farkas on Monday October 03, 2011 @07:04PM (#3068576)
It's fine. However, we would recommend pushing and pulling over SSH for speed.

And let me clarify: by fair-use we mean we offer unlimited _code_ hosting, not general storage. We monitor for abuse, such as large repos containing only music, videos, and public viruses or malware. Though don't worry - if we notice any problems we'd of course contact you first.

We'd love to have you as a customer!

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by danieldk on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @02:05AM (#3069625)
Farkas, thank you for this information!
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by lyddonb on Monday October 03, 2011 @11:01PM (#3069164)
My company is currently debating between Github and Bitbucket. And the funny thing is git vs hg wasn't really an issue. We've decided that either is so much better than svn that we'd take either.

We have 2 large road blocks for Bitbucket. First is a real nice review system with inline comments during a pull request. Is this coming soon? It's an absolute deal breaker for us.

Also the performance/usability seems to be lacking compared to Github. I hope that changes. Although we also use JiraStudio and it's performance is dreadful. And the usability is quite frustrating. So the Atlassian track record is a little worrying for us.

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by farkas on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @01:03AM (#3069467)
I really appreciate the feedback. Whilst I can't comment on future releases, I want to assure you that we are aware of the items you mention. Stay tuned :)
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by ergo14 on Monday October 03, 2011 @01:04PM (#3067119)
Yeah, I'm a happy developer that uses both bitbucket and github - I'd just wish that ui for bb gets nicer and more friendly - and it will be perfect tool for me.
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by nessus42 on Monday October 03, 2011 @12:55PM (#3067078)
<<Has any popular git hosting site added mercurial support?>>

Yes. In fact Github implemented the Git plugin for Mercurial that lets you use Github (or any Git repository) with Mercurial as your client rather than Git.

I guess this shows which DVCS is winning?

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by eropple on Monday October 03, 2011 @01:10PM (#3067144)
As noted upthread, hg-git is a very poor facade.

The problem I have with git isn't in its syntax. It's in more central decisions with which I disagree fairly strenuously (I am very strongly in favor of indelible history, for example).

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by wnight on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @01:14AM (#3069496)
Git history is indelible too. I mean, you can't mess with an existing tree without it being obvious.

But in any VCS you can of course start over. Set the system clock back and check the existing code from another repo into a new one in different chunks making it appear to have been made differently in the first place. There's no way around that other than signing your commits which would work in git as well...

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by tzury on Tuesday October 04, 2011 @01:13AM (#3069489)

    This shows which DVCS is winning.
There is no war. hence, no winners, no losers.

Why on earth, in the software world, taste / choice diversity is immediately considered as a war?

There is the editors war, DVCS war, OS war, Browsers war.

Let's give peace a chance!

Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by alexknowshtml on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:29AM (#3075030)
Beanstalk (http://beanstalkapp.com) has added Mercurial to our Git and SVN support - it's in private beta right now, but you can email me [email protected] if you're interested in being added.
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by josephcooney on Monday October 03, 2011 @07:25PM (#3068651)
Google Code, and Microsoft's CodePlex have, yes.
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by josephcooney on Monday October 03, 2011 @07:29PM (#3068662)
Oops...I mis-read your question. I thought you asked "Has any popular hosting site added mercurial support?"
Re:Bitbucket now rocks Git by przemoc on Monday October 03, 2011 @07:34PM (#3068682)
At least Google Code supports git for some time already. :)

http://google-opensource.blogspot.com/2011/07/announcing-git...