Re:Tokamak Energy sets a temperature record among commercial...
by jleahy on Sunday March 13, 2022 @05:47PM
(#30666062)
No you're quite right, that's why I said "...maximum energy states (this is assuming there is one)". Of course with no upper bound on energy this isn't possible, that's the definition straight up, just like you say.
In particular even with a quantum non-interacting gas with particle-in-a-box modes, the Hamiltonian is not bounded from above and there is no reason to expect a negative temperature, no?
There exist systems, like spin systems, where energy is bounded from above and so entropy decreases as you add energy, which is the definition of negative temperature... But I find it dubious that every system is such, unless I am missing something nonintuitive about say relativistic effects or so