Re:How 3D Printing Will Save American Manufacturing
by biot on Monday October 03, 2011 @03:46PM
(#3067702)
I was the one who said bookshelf (no edits were made). I made it out of planks of wood and wood screws. The Ikea bookshelf uses wood planks but of a lighter/less durable kind of wood. I'm sure mine might have held up cast iron books where the Ikea version would have failed, but as a regular bookshelf for paper books, the price/performance of the Ikea product would have met my needs more than adequately at a decent cost savings.
Even so, the 3' x 2' bit of 'wood product' from ikea costs almost as much as a 4'x8' piece of 'wood product' from home depot. That's more than 5 ikea tables worth of wood.
I think the dramatically increased price (percentage wise, of course, not dollar wise) of the ikea part is in the addition of the laminate on top and on the sides; you can't really cut the laminated particle board to size once you get it, unless you want exposed sawdust-wood, so we are back to manu
I mean, I'm not saying the ikea stuff isn't good; I'm just saying that they, generally speaking, are charging considerably more (as a percentage, not in terms of dollars, and for a $7 item, even if their markup is 4x, well, you probably aren't going to notice.) than what materials cost.