News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ballistic missiles hit Iraq's Kurdish capital, no casualt... by sudosysgen on Saturday March 12, 2022 @08:47PM (#30657063)
How so?
Re:Ballistic missiles hit Iraq's Kurdish capital, no casualt... by ZanyProgrammer on Saturday March 12, 2022 @08:59PM (#30657147)
Are you totally sure the same systems that defend US naval vessels are present in Erbil, Iraq?
Re:Ballistic missiles hit Iraq's Kurdish capital, no casualt... by sudosysgen on Saturday March 12, 2022 @09:15PM (#30657233)
They definitely aren't. Supposedly there is Patriot and C-RAM, whereas warships use AEGIS.

However, Patriot is based on largely the same technology as AEGIS (PESA engagement radar, TVM, Hit-to-kill capability, etc...), is supposed to have a high kill probability against these targets, and like the SM-3, is made by Raytheon.

So if Patriot can't intercept SRBMs reliably, it's unlikely that another missile system made by the same company using the same technology could intercept MRBMs reliably.

Re:Ballistic missiles hit Iraq's Kurdish capital, no casualt... by tyingq on Saturday March 12, 2022 @09:39PM (#30657344)
>largely the same technology

At a high level right? Like both "PESA" radars, but completely different implementations. Similar, but not at all the same missles, etc.

And it's not clear a Patriot system was in Irbil, in the right spot anyway, right?

So this all could mean something, but that's unclear.

Re:Ballistic missiles hit Iraq's Kurdish capital, no casualt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 13, 2022 @10:19AM (#30661410)
It seems the air defences were indeed in Erbil: https://globalcomment.com/how-effective-air-defences-in-iraq...

As far as implementation, yes of course the implementation would be different, but it bears to notice it is made by the same company. Is it really reasonable to expect Raytheon to fail at making competent air defences and greatly overstate their capabilities for Patriot, whereas their naval missiles are nearly perfect?