News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The tech industry controls CS conference funding. What ar... by saagarjha on Saturday March 12, 2022 @05:02PM (#30655359)
This is basically my point, though. The things you’ve said (which are basically just what Google pushes) are correct. For their use case, they’ve found some good wins and there’s lots of interesting things under the hood enabling this. That’s cool, but these improvements come at a cost: the ABI (and in some cases, the API) is different. For Google this is OK because they can just ask their clients to adapt. This might be fine for you as well. But it’s definitely not the case for everyone, and ignoring it (at best) or actively harping on the standard for making concessions for the “dumb” reason of stability is not appropriate.
Re:The tech industry controls CS conference funding. What ar... by tialaramex on Saturday March 12, 2022 @10:47PM (#30657735)
I think you're arguing against a straw man? Maybe you can give a concrete example of the behaviour you're concerned about.

Neither of the Google C++ Swiss Table presentations I've seen were about how somehow std::unordered_set can be replaced by this completely different thing. The existing container is just useless, that's sad but there's nothing to be done about it because the ABI break cost is unacceptable.

Instead the talks were about why this thing (Swiss Tables) makes sense, how you can make use of it in your own software, and maybe about tricks you can use in your own data structures, or about how Hyrum's law interacts with this work.