Re:RISC-V J extension – Instructions for JITs
by jasonwatkinspdx on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:39AM
(#30650250)
So, with RISC-V the design pretty deliberately enables a combination of compressed instructions and macro op fusion.
The compressed instructions are quite lightweight. It's generally an assembly level thing, and the decoder on the cpu side is apparently ~400 gates.
The compressed instructions are indeed a 16 bit wide thing, but fixing some of the flaws in Thumb. Generally they have more implicit operands or operands range over a subset of registers to fit in 16 bits.
But the hat trick is these two dovetail into each other, such that a sequence of compressed instructions can decompress into a fuse-able pair/tuple, which then decodes into a single internal micro op. This creates a way to handle common idioms and special cases without introducing an ever growing number of instructions. Or at least that's the basic claim by the RISC-V folks. I think they've done enough homework on this to not be trivially wrong, so it'll be interesting to see how things go.
The compressed instructions are quite lightweight. It's generally an assembly level thing, and the decoder on the cpu side is apparently ~400 gates.
The compressed instructions are indeed a 16 bit wide thing, but fixing some of the flaws in Thumb. Generally they have more implicit operands or operands range over a subset of registers to fit in 16 bits.
But the hat trick is these two dovetail into each other, such that a sequence of compressed instructions can decompress into a fuse-able pair/tuple, which then decodes into a single internal micro op. This creates a way to handle common idioms and special cases without introducing an ever growing number of instructions. Or at least that's the basic claim by the RISC-V folks. I think they've done enough homework on this to not be trivially wrong, so it'll be interesting to see how things go.