News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by userbinator on Friday March 11, 2022 @08:34PM (#30648164)
It's true that it won't know the exact pressures, but it certainly knows which tire is spinning faster than all the others (due to the lower pressure, it has shrunk) so it could definitely tell you to check that one.

In fact, your example looks more like one overinflated (or perhaps overheated) tire --- RR.

Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by svnt on Friday March 11, 2022 @08:45PM (#30648216)
You seem to contradict yourself in this post. You say they can tell one is spinning faster than all the others, however this one could also easily be the one inflated to the correct pressure, while the other three are overinflated. If the Volvo tells you to correct it and it is wrong, it could keep telling you to overinflate tires indefinitely. This could be why they don’t, which was OP’s original point.
Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by culopatin on Sunday March 13, 2022 @09:57AM (#30661239)
When you inflate them you press the “set” button so it knows what the base is. If one suddenly starts geting more angular velocity constantly than it’s likely it lost air
Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by kube-system on Sunday March 13, 2022 @01:18PM (#30663424)
Yes, if one decreases relative to the other, it’s easy to figure out that one changed.

You still don’t know for sure that it needs inflated, because:

1. setting tire pressures incorrectly is not uncommon

2. That button is user accessible and might be pressed inadvertently or by someone who didn’t set the tires correctly

3. If all tires change in pressure at the same time, it would be undetectable

This is why these systems generally tell you to “check” your tires, rather than inflate a specific one. If they made that assumption, your car could be telling you to inflate an already overinflated tire.

Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by culopatin on Sunday March 13, 2022 @03:51PM (#30665042)
1. Just check the tires. 2. Read the manual 3. Not sure about every implementation but it still possible to tell by storing wheel rpm associated with engine rpm, gear and steering angle the first few miles after setting it.

There are many cars with tpms in the wheel that still won’t tell you what wheel it is or what’s the pressure, so I still much rather have no sensor to deal with trading the “inconvenience” of checking the tires once the light comes on, which is what you would do anyway.

Re:You don't ever own an electric vehicle by kube-system on Sunday March 13, 2022 @09:15PM (#30667479)
I think you’re misunderstanding me. I’m not complaining about the functionality. I think it is good functionality, and I personally prefer iTPMS.

I was explaining why the engineering of the system dictates the information that the interface provides.