Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by pjsg on Friday March 11, 2022 @09:23AM
(#30640246)
Of course, it wouldn't have helped in this case as it was the third party site that had the bad certificate. That fact is not signalled anywhere. I don't recall anybody (even the most ardent supporters of EV) saying that the browser should warn you if any third party references were not EV.
Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by dboreham on Friday March 11, 2022 @10:55AM
(#30641404)
That doesn't make sense since any content loaded from a second site has the ability to compromise the first. If nobody said that, they weren't thinking hard enough. Browsers already have this kind of transitive security enforcement -- you can't load a page with TLS that then pulls JS via plaintext http.
Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by nilsbunger on Friday March 11, 2022 @09:57AM
(#30640672)
But EV would give you a way to make a more secure website by hosting all the content yourself
Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by lexicality on Friday March 11, 2022 @10:02AM
(#30640739)
You think every website with a form on it should have to pay hundreds of dollars per year to certificate authorities?
Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by natpalmer1776 on Friday March 11, 2022 @11:07AM
(#30641587)
I think if a website with a form on it that involves transferring any sum of money around should pay hundreds of dollars per year to certificate authorities.
Not every building needs to implement the security measures of Fort Knox. That doesn't mean that the security measures in-place at Fort Knox shouldn't exist.
Re:Attackers exploit flaw in web’s security to steal $2M in ...
by sp332 on Friday March 11, 2022 @10:30AM
(#30641070)
There should be a quick, visible way for a user to tell the difference between a connection that is merely encrypted and one where the identity of the certificate owner has been vetted. Then the user can decide for any given form whether they are comfortable sending that data over that kind of connection.
Sometimes, the alternative to companies paying hundreds of dollars per year is customers losing millions.
Rather the conclusion should've been that the browser gives the user a warning when attempting to submit information to a website that doesn't have an EV security certificate.
Or at the very least allow websites to use HSTS to prevent downgrading an EV certificate.