News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: As non-nuke power, why fight a nuke power, esp if... by dragonwriter on Friday March 11, 2022 @05:19AM (#30638265)
> The easy out for Ukraine was to just go neutral

No, it wasn’t.

Heck, Russia’s ultimatum before attacking Ukraine wasn’t mostly directed at Ukraine, but at NATO, and at withdrawing from the entire Eastern European part of NATO, giving up further expansion, and not even doing exercises in the Eastern part of NATO (much less with non-NATO partners in Eastern Europe) without advance permission from (not notice to) Russia. (It also included a permanent ban on Ukraine joining NATO, but since it featured a permanent ban on NATO expansion as well, that was kind of redundant.)

> Europe was _so_ intent on pleasing their master, the US, that they intentionally and recklessly followed _this_ path?

The Eastern European members of the EU and NATO (which are virtually the same) have more concern about checking Russian bullying of its neighbors than either Western Europe or the US.

> If there’s not a moral reason for it

There is. The moral reason is not rewarding Russia's fairly consistent warmongering and bullying against its neighbors for the last couple decades.

> and there’s not a realpolitik reason for it

There’s that too. Its in part the same as the moral reason (to the extent that it can be described with the same words), but not because of the morality of rewarding the behavior, but because of the reasonably forseeable consequences of rewarding it, and how for everyone concerned who isn’t Ukraine (but especially the other Eastern European countries), its better that the hard fighting that is inevitable wherever the line is drawn is drawn where the conflict is now than where it would be next time.

There are no comments on this comment yet.