News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by diffeomorphism on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @02:58AM (#30612000)
Those are nice smart home features, but why do you need specifically voice for that?

For example, displaying a rain cloud symbol and temperature seems just as effective and quicker than asking alexa.

Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by razemio on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @03:47AM (#30612275)
He specifically mentioned that he controls a lot from the car. How would you do this without support for voice commands?

The little speakers can be put into every room, almost invisible, and for a fraction of the cost of a smart display.

Also, at night, smart displays suck. They always turn on, when you do not need them. Waking you up on the way to the toilet.

Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by diffeomorphism on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @08:26AM (#30614148)
Not while I am driving and then by using my phone obviously.

Lots of these tasks are completely automatic (e.g. locking doors, announcements, turn things off when I am gone, motion sensors....) or simple inputs, e.g. volume buttons or a slider for oven temp.

> The little speakers can be put into every room, almost invisible, and for a fraction of the cost of a smart display.

My phone is in my pocket and thus in every room I am in.

So let me rephrase the question: If I use my phone, for which things is voice input so much better than just clicking on widgets?

Thus far I think hands-free while cooking and the UX for music/video are the standard examples. The question above was: Besides this, what are great use cases?

Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by vineyardmike on Thursday March 10, 2022 @03:50PM (#30632250)
> My phone is in my pocket and thus in every room I am in.

Not everyone does this. Eg. My parents use Alexa but keep their cell phone by the door or on their nightstand.

> So let me rephrase the question: If I use my phone, for which things is voice input so much better than just clicking on widgets?

You already answered one: Cooking, etc. But also some people have other household members. The communal nature of the device matches the communal nature of a household. If I hear an announcement saying to put laundry in drier, I can act on it even if I didn't start laundry. Or if there's an timer to take something out of oven, I can act even if the cook is in the bathroom.

Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by wkearney99 on Saturday March 12, 2022 @06:14AM (#30650602)
Voice needs no physical mode-switching. Ask and receive regardless of whether you've got your hands full doing something else, or looking at something else, or don't have your phone super-glued to your person.

There's also no tangential distraction when looking up information. If I'm going to travel I can ask for the forecast (daily or weekly) at places along the way without getting bogged down with unrelated web browsing or advertising.

Re:S.e.p.i.a. – Digital voice assistant by michaelmior on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @06:30AM (#30613372)
Voice has the advantage that you don't need line of sight. If I think of the range of locations where a voice assistant can hear and respond, it's much larger than what could be easily covered by displays.