News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:29PM (#3061157)
A founder who believes in his business, will never cash out early. period.

He would always get more after an IPO or exit. So why would he?

I assume the founders are not stupid, they know their valuation is not justified.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by todojunkie on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:56PM (#3061236)
"A founder who believes in his business, will never cash out early. period."

That is just not true.

You have zero clue of any one founders back story. How many years have they been building their business and not taking a pay check? Not taking health insurance? Struggling... Taking a payout, in some cases, can motivate someone who has been putting in 24/7 for year(s) to keep going. It can also allow the people in your life (family) to support you in pushing forward with your passions.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by Murkin on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:51PM (#3061220)
You missed the point, they take the money as dividens.

They are not selling their stock for that $20M lump.

The only 'foul' thing here, is that their employees (option holders) will probably get nothing.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by prostoalex on Saturday October 01, 2011 @10:46PM (#3061869)
I don't pretend to know the ins and outs of this, but the dividend is to common stock. What if the next step after closing the deal would be founders telling employees to exercise as much as possible, and then announce the dividend?

Granted, most of that money would probably have gone towards AMT, but let's not vilify AirBnB before we hear their end of the story.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by philwelch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @06:28PM (#3061321)
Well, and that investors are being asked to "invest" millions of dollars into the founders' personal wealth.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @06:19PM (#3061296)
They sold shares for 20 Million to the investors to pay out this dividend, so the outcome is the same.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @08:23PM (#3061599)
Am i wrong?
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:34PM (#3061170)
This line of thinking has been thoroughly discredited. Many of the most successful companies today had founders that took money off the table early.

If they didn't believe in the company they could just sell it today for $500 million (or whatever) and put $50 million in their pockets instead of $5 million.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by steve8918 on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:07PM (#3061409)
Taking money off the table implies selling their stake, ie. shares. They didn't sell their shares. They gave themselves a one-time dividend.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:33PM (#3061468)
You're right that selling shares is far more common, but the concept is the same. The founders raised an extra $20 million so they could sock it away themselves.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by colinplamondon on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:35PM (#3061177)
What? It's a whole lot easier to swing for the fences when you're already a millionaire.

Selling 5% of your total shares for $3,000,000 sets you up well for life. Not great, but well. At 4% interest that's $120k/year. After that, it's gravy.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by angryasian on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:43PM (#3061201)
it also makes it a whole lot easier if the company is on shaky ground and built up by hype, when everything does happen to implode in on itself. I'm not saying that this is airbnb's case but ...

I'm not saying twitter is a failure by any means, but none of the people that built the company are still there ( Jack Dorsey started square so maybe he is that small percentage of people that can juggle two amazing startups ). When all the founders cash out early, it just makes it questionable.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:42PM (#3061198)
It also takes a lot of pressure from you and maybe distracts from building the company.

On Wallstreet they call this "fuck you money".

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @06:38PM (#3061344)
In Silicon Valley all the best people aren't in it just for the money. Can't say that about Wall Street.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by veyron on Saturday October 01, 2011 @09:48PM (#3061763)
As a person in Wall Street who isn't in it just for the money, I resent your remark.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @11:38PM (#3061977)
There are probably a few exceptions. Do you honestly disagree with the sentiment?
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by veyron on Sunday October 02, 2011 @12:04AM (#3062026)
I was giving you a hard time. I don't think there's a significant percentage of people in finance for any reason other than money.

I am utterly fascinated with the capital markets and many aspects of finance. The returns reflect a true understanding of the markets. And yes, for the record, tech startups are in many ways less stressful than finance startups :)

As far as "altruism" is concerned, the value-add to society is wholly artificial: if our financial systems weren't structured to force retirement and pension funds to invest in the capital markets, I highly doubt anyone would say they were doing something good for the world.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by angryasian on Saturday October 01, 2011 @06:51PM (#3061376)
keep drinking the kool-aid
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:21PM (#3061449)
You must think Steve Jobs has spent the last few years working at Apple, when he probably should have been doing something less stressful, because he wants yet another billion dollars?
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:51PM (#3061502)
What are you talking about?

Total off topic.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @08:02PM (#3061532)
I'm giving a example of someone who exemplifies the Silicon Valley mentality that I refer to above.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @08:14PM (#3061565)
We were talking about people who do the exact opposite and try to get FU-money before they led companies to success.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @08:22PM (#3061594)
Airbnb makes many millions in revenue and has phenomenal growth. They could easily sell the company today for hundreds of millions. That is success.

Instead of selling though, they're raising more money, taking some out themselves, and setting their sights on an even higher level of success.

Makes sense to me.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @09:01PM (#3061681)
Well i see a company with strong competitors, high costs, no competitive advantage and insurance risks.

Their product is an inferior version of hotel rooms.

There is a high possibility that they are bankrupt some day.

What the founders are doing makes perfect sense to me, maybe there will never be an IPO or Exit.

Maybe studying economics diseased my brain, but i can't see why competitiveness doesn't matter any more.

Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by brandnewlow on Saturday October 01, 2011 @05:50PM (#3061213)
Zuckerberg, Moskovitz, and Parker each got $1m from Accel when they raised their $12.7m Series A according to David Kirkpatrick's The Facebook Effect.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by sek on Saturday October 01, 2011 @06:02PM (#3061253)
The reason there was competition between VCs, this is a different motivation and the amount is not that high.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by ebaysucks on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:14PM (#3061430)
$3M on 12.7M investment is higher percentage wise than what the Airbnb guys are asking. Plus, it's earlier stage.
Re:VC Decries Airbnb’s Recent Funding for Founder Control an... by staunch on Saturday October 01, 2011 @07:29PM (#3061464)
And the Airbnb deal is probably a lot more competitive. Facebook was hot, but the market wasn't.