News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @02:19PM (#306083)
Why is it that everything I read in this blog pisses me off?

Yes. Of course there is. We aren't nearly at the point yet where the Internet works as quickly as hardware. We don't have a world with wonderful connections everywhere. Desktop apps are leagues faster in every regard. And I'd say we need a long time before that'll be fixed.

Plus, once you work inside a web browser, you don't just have the layer abstraction, you have a visual abstraction. Know what I like about Mail and Newsfire? The fact that they have ultraminimal interfaces for what they do. When I stick that inside Safari, I suddenly have something that's uglier than the original thing was. Even MobileMe suffers from that visually.

For somebody whose URL would imply a high level of criticism, which is always good, these posts always seem to advocate very sucky things.

Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by raganwald on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:24PM (#306186)
Why is it that everything I read in this blog pisses me off?

Uh, because you're human, and like the rest of us, you take incredibly trivial things far too personally? Seriously, if I asked you whether somewhere on this Earth we can find someone whose views are diametrically opposed to yours AND they express them in a manner you find obnoxious, I guess you would say that statistically, that person--call him "un-unalone"--is out there somewhere.

And no, you wouldn't get pissed off knowing that un-unalone exists and is being vehemently wrong every time he speaks. But if we conjure un-unalone up for you and you read what he's actually writing, you get angry.

I guess we'd all like to be perfectly Zen about this, and shrug our shoulders, but we aren't and we don't.

FWIW, I think Jeff Atwood is pretty-much the un-raganwald, right down to being waaaaaaaaaaay more likable than I am :-)

Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by axod on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:20PM (#306178)
Quite a lot of people just run webapps in prism etc these days, so they pretty much look like desktop apps.
Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by unalone on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:29PM (#306429)
Nah, sorry. Not the came. The mere existence of a shell means you've got more interface than is actually necessary.
Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by axod on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @03:38AM (#306791)
A shell? I don't follow.
Re:Is there any reason for desktop apps anymore? by unalone on Wednesday September 17, 2008 @06:53PM (#307648)
With a desktop app, the windows of the app is part of the interface. With any SSB, the window just takes away screen space.