If the US leadership over the last thirty years was even a little less unscrupulous and short-sighted, we could have averted this geopolitical catastrophe currently unfolding in Eastern Europe, but I'm sure the fact that "Putin started it" will be great comfort when the nukes start falling and everyone you knew or cared about is dead.
Two wrongs don't make a right, now do they? I find it mind boggling that such an act of agression can be made immune to critique because "some other country did it worse that one time."
So instead of trying to assign blame, lets try to resolve this situation to all parties' benefit, rather than lionizing one side, and demonizing the other. Which ultimately means taking Russia's security concerns and legitimate grievances seriously, because if this gets out of hand, then it will be to the whole world's sorrow.
But right now, the crisis at hand is that Russia has invaded Ukraine and Putin has lied again and again. How can we take Russia's grievances seriously when Putin has been acting on bad faith all along.
The crisis at hand is that we have, along with our counterparties in Russia and the EU, created a region of instability along the outer Soviet arc that has existed since its formal collapse in 1991. This war in Ukraine is just the latest manifestation of this.
I personally would like my government to try and negotiate with Putin, and to make an honest effort to address his concerns, in an attempt to put an end to hostilities. How many more times do we have in us, to creep along the edge of nuclear war, are you all so eager for the grave? Clearly you feel differently, and I guess that's where we will have to disagree.
Putins acts have demonstrated that Ukraine’s desires to join the EU and NATO are absolutely warranted, to protect themselves from exactly this.
Additionally, Putin has threatened anyone that gets in his way from getting what he wants with nuclear war. We can debate about whether it’s an idle threat or not but if it’s true, then that and his attack on civilians shows that he has no regard for human life, that he would rather face his own peoples annihilation if it means he can also punish those who stand in his way. Someone making such threats, and who had a clear history of lying, cannot be trusted. What does listening to him achieve if nothing he says can be trusted? Nothing he agrees can be trusted, so what agreement can possibly be made?
The invasion of Ukraine was premeditated, he was planning it for many many months based on the movement of troops and equipment and the leaked reports I heard about. This wasn’t a reaction to a breakdown in diplomacy, this was a long planned invasion.
I’m not saying we should invade Russia back and I’m not saying we shouldn’t take great care when dealing with the situation. I am saying that Putin cannot be trusted and I fear diplomacy doesn’t work against someone whose promises cannot be trusted and someone who has shown to have great ambitions yet also a callous disregard for human life. I also don’t think we can reasonably assume that he won’t use nuclear weapons when his attack on Ukraine is becoming increasingly brutal as he’s getting more desperate.
So what are we to do? Just give him what he wants? Show him and the rest of the world that brutality and threatening nuclear war gets you whatever you ask for?
Where was everyone during the last 8 years during the Donbass war where Ukraine deployed battalions composed of neo-nazis against unarmed civilians?
Further unapproved thoughts from approved sources:
1. US ambassador decided who they'll pick for the puppet during the 2014 coup, right on this call: https://youtu.be/WV9J6sxCs5k
2. Ukraine is the only country with an official neo-Nazi battalion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azov_Battalion
3. Ukraine parliament speaker was an open anti-semite and neo-nazi, and also served as minister of national security(!): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andriy_Parubiy https://www.channel4.com/news/svoboda-ministers-ukraine-new-...
4. Ukraine commits assaults and arson against their rather sizable ethnic minorities, again, using their neo-nazi groups: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/02/ukraine-dead-o...
5. Ukraine has neo-nazis at every level of their government: https://youtu.be/KfaAyiP8Wuc
6. Ukrainians killing civilians for 8 years using the same neo-nazi battalions mentioned above: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Donbas
Just as Ukraine refused humanitarian corridors during the last 8 years in Donbass, they are refusing them now to their own civilians to exit cities under siege.
It's amazing how people think Ukraine is this shining beacon of freedom and Russia is this evil orc empire, when in fact, they both have the same transparency score, aka just as corrupt.
Now tell me, how is recognizing independence of a province populated by a persecuted ethnic group, and then marshalling troops to protect it any different from NATO vs Kosovo?
The minority is Russian, so I guess it's a safe pre-approved behaviour to hate them and ignore their persecution by literally self-admitted neo-nazis.
Go ahead and support Nazis openly.
Now it seems that he is going to be downvoted to oblivion but I think he shouldn’t. Why? It’s exactly this kind of opposite and constructed opinion (right or wrong really it doesn’t matter) that help us to be better critical thinkers and get a better view of the world. If he is wrong then we will know even more why about the subject. If he is right then our views have now dramatically changed! Now of course we have to take time ourselves to go to his material, in the rabbit hole of infos, fact check, check the sources etc… Or else we are no better than the other person we disagree with! Just lucky to be on the right side. Or! Not even knowing that we are in the wrong one and never being able to know it without putting the effort!
Thanks to his comment and going down to the rabbit hole of infos and fact checking etc… I now know a lot more about what’s going there, Ukraine, the geopolitical states, Russia… and also why people may think like OP. Doesn’t mean I agree. But I have now a lot better and wider understanding than before. And that’s too bad to not respect people that just help ourselves to achieve that even if we disagree with them.
So? Many people equally believe that the Iraq war was unjustified. Just because someone else does something bad, doesn't give you the right or an excuse to also do something bad.
> Nobody is going to launch nukes, that’s just silly.
Right up until Putin invaded Ukraine, everybody was saying he won't invade Ukraine, that's just silly. But he did anyway. You don't know what Putin will or won't do, especially now that Ukraine turned out to not be so easy to take and the world has largely banded together against him. If he's backed into a corner and feels that he's doomed either way, then who knows what he is willing to do.
> He will likely just void IP rights and patents in retaliation to sanctions.
He can go for it.
He was already threatening nuclear if he doesn't get what he wants. If he's serious about that, nothing the west does besides rolling over and just giving him the world will stop him from doing that and giving in to him will, in my opinion, only embolden him by showing him that his threats get him results.
If he wants to end the sanctions, then he can withdraw from Ukraine and we'll go from there.
Remember also that Putin lied multiple times: its just a military exercise, not invading, you're crazy (then he invaded); civilians won't be targeted or harmed (and then he started targeting and killing civilians). Nothing he promises or says can be trusted.
Having said that, its all rather difficult. If he's backed into a corner and sees no other way out, what's stopping him from going "Fuck it, I'm screwed either way, launch the nukes"...