News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Native Matrix VoIP with Element Call by jeroenhd on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:28AM (#30568843)
For what it's worth, Matrix / Element already have something like this with the built-in Jitsi integration in (some) clients. The UX isn't great right now in my opinion (which will hopefully change when this project gets merged into Element) but if all you want is rooms, text and voice, then you're already set with the current setup.

You can self-host a Jitsi instance and use it in Matrix rooms as an integration. Depending on your teamspeak setup you can enable guest access to your server, enable registration for server user accounts (or manually register it for specific members), or only let people with existing accounts from other servers join in (their own, matrix.org ones, you name it). You might also need to tweak the ACLs a bit, but other than that you'll have all the core features Teamspeak and friends provide.

I think the biggest difference between the existing Matrix group call system and what's been announced here today is the new UI/UX, and the fact that the native group call API and reference implementation are nearing completion. Both are great news, but don't necessarily add new user-facing features to the Matrix ecosystem.

Re:Native Matrix VoIP with Element Call by georgyo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:13PM (#30569414)
The UX is more than terrible, it is basically unusable.

The jitsi stuff is bolted on, you join a link and your user name does not come with you.

No discoverablity. Does this channel already have a jitsi room attached, no way to know. I see a link to a jitsi room, is there anyone inside? No way to know.

Recommending this as a alternative to TeamSpeak, mumble, or discord today is a way to get people to try a horrible experience and then say Matrix sucks forever.

Only when this call stuff merges will Matrix start being viable for those communities.

Re:Native Matrix VoIP with Element Call by anticensor on Saturday March 05, 2022 @03:52PM (#30571748)
TeamSpeak 5 actually uses Matrix under the hood, with a proprietary voice protocol and TeamSpeak-specific room version.
Re:Native Matrix VoIP with Element Call by GeckoEidechse on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:45AM (#30569059)
Yes but the current UX for that is terrible. With the proposed MSC linked in the blog post, Matrix will additionally gain Teamspeak/Discord like voice channels [1].

With this we could finally have a proper Teamspeak/Mumble bridge for voice that gets properly represented on the Matrix side which is amazing :D

Also kinda funny that Teamspeak only recently started using Matrix for their global chat feature [2].

Maybe now after the gitter acquisition, Element should consider acquiring a certain voice-focused company ;)

**

[1] https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/blob/mat...

[2] https://community.teamspeak.com/t/teamspeak-5-beta-bug-repor...