You're ignoring the money market here. I just looked up some numbers, and Forrester research peged the amount of deposits at FDIC insured banks at $6.9 trillion at the end of 2007 (http://www.forrester.com/rb/Research/industry_essential_us_r..., although the number of insured dollars is probably a fair bit lower than that due to limits on the size of insurable deposits), while the Institutional Money Market Funds Association gives $3.6 trillion in money market funds. Money market funds are marketed as being equivalent to bank deposits (down to the ability to write checks against them) and many retail investors don't understand that they aren't insured.
I recall reading (think this was in Too Big To Fail) that the deciding powers were afraid that if there was another Lehman, cash would stop coming out of the ATM machines. This is what prompted AIG and a few of the other shotgun marriages.