I put energy into cofounding Blue Oak Council to publish rigorous resources, like our permissive license list, https://blueoakcouncil.org/list, in large part out of disappointment and dread, pulling back the curtain on the institutional processes for license review. As lawyers, we need functional resources like that license list, to incorporate by reference into contracts and policies. Fundamentally political artifacts, like OSI or FSF or Debian whitelists, are type errors in those contexts.
> everybody knows what MIT, BSD, Apache, and the various GPL licenses imply
I'm afraid that's not true. I would say there is broad agreement on many of the core aspects. And in many situations, practically, the specific license terms don't matter nearly as much as widely help expectations. But key concepts affecting fairly common situations remain unclear, and those details come out when there's money or strategic leverage on the line. See, e.g. the list Heather Meeker keeps at https://heathermeeker.com/open-source-faq/what-are-the-most-... See also the whole debate on permissive licenses and standards-essential patents: https://writing.kemitchell.com/2019/10/03/Open-Standards.htm....
Any chance you could change the slug on that first link from Rely-on-OSI to Dont-Rely-on-OSI-Approval or similar? The current URL suggests the opposite of the article’s content. Hopefully adding a redirect isn’t too onerous.
As a more casual person looking to use a license, this is basically the opposite of what I want to read.
As a non-lawyer, I have little chance of vetting a license myself. As a person with life experience, I have full appreciation for the delicacy of these kinds of licenses and legal issues.
If a license has consensus from OSI, FSF, Debian, maybe a FANG company or two, etc., then I have some trust that a kind of validation and peer review has occurred. I fear that using a license for which this has not occurred puts the users of my software at risk, or at least shifts the burden of future validation on to them.
TLDR: everybody knows what MIT, BSD, Apache, and the various GPL licenses imply. I think other bespoke licenses have a pretty high bar to clear before they become truly useful.