News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by alexwennerberg on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:14AM (#30555004)
Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by rdpintqogeogsaa on Friday March 04, 2022 @11:22AM (#30556806)
0BSD is actually incompatible with a desired pure CC0. Unlike CC0, 0BSD keeps copyright intact. It's just a license with no conditions except the usual disclaimer; CC0 attempts to cause a public domain dedication wherever possible. Consider the following:

1. Let there be a file F. F is released to the public under 0BSD.

2. Let there be a project P. P includes code from F. The license notice of F is scrubbed as part of the inclusion process.

3. P is released as CC0.

The author of P cannot release the project as CC0 because the author has no right dedicate another person's code (F) to the public domain. Because 0BSD doesn't cause a public domain dedication in jurisdictions that accept doing so, F would have to continue being separate and explicitly exempt from the effects of CC0 to be an accurate of its usage terms. Effectively, this makes 0BSD be a de-facto attribution license in a CC0 project. In practice, it makes no difference, but it's legally deeply inelegant.

Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by hannob on Friday March 04, 2022 @10:01AM (#30555763)
Fails on criterion 4, and I think that's a real issue.

Github is the de-facto default sourcecode plattform. If it isn't a standard option on Github then it doesn't feel like a standard license.

Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by ahelwer on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:27AM (#30555202)
Not an alike license.
Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by marcinzm on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:44AM (#30555482)
...isn't that literally the opposite of public domain? You can't have it both be public domain with no copyright and ALSO use copyright to enforce what people do with their copies of it.
Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by freemint on Friday March 04, 2022 @09:42AM (#30555454)
What do you mean? CC0 and 0BSD are both public domain equivalent.
Re:The Unlicense is an inferior license wrapped in an atroci... by ghaff on Friday March 04, 2022 @10:26AM (#30556070)
CC0 isn't an OSI-approved license. (It was withdrawn from consideration around patent language concerns.) MIT-0 (or probably 0BSD now as well) is probably the closest you get to a public domain license to the degree that putting something in the public domain is recognized in a given jurisdiction.