News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by MikeTaylor on Thursday September 29, 2011 @06:41PM (#3054631)
I made a mistake in the original article when I chose the phrase "handling fee", which suggests that the journal charges just for evaluating your manucript. That's not how it works (in the great majority of cases anyway) -- you pay only if your paper is accepted and published. (So I should have called it a "publication fee".)

This is an important difference because it means you don't have a situation where someone submits a manuscript, pays the handling fee, and feels the journal owes them positive reviews and publication.

Many open-access journals provide waivers for authors without institutional funding. Typically, editorial staff and reviewers and not informed whether or not the author took a waiver, so that can't influence the accept/reject decision.

There are no comments on this comment yet.