News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research: ‘Ukraine war costs Russian military €20B per day’ by dragonwriter on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:14AM (#30538879)
> lost equipment costs basically 0 - they are mostly old hand-me-downs, the factories are not producing them anymore, so all the costs are already sunk;

Sure, for some legacy capital items, the production costs are sunk. But the cost of not having the equipment isn't. You can pay replacement cost or you can pay the permanent reduction in military capacity cost, but you are paying the cost either way if you lose the equipment.

Unless you are saying the operational value of the equipment is zero, in which case, sure, the loss is zero but then why did you even bring it to war in the first place?

> airplanes are more expensive, but again, this is old stock, there is plenty of them, and not incurring costs of producing more - let's say 10M per craft

If you aren't calculating it at the cost of replacing the capacity provided, you are underestimating the real cost.

Re:Research: ‘Ukraine war costs Russian military €20B per day’ by lobocinza on Thursday March 03, 2022 @08:37AM (#30540785)
Cash flow is a present issue while CAPEX is an issue for the future and can be spread along years. Most of what Russia sent to fight (except the jets and Pantsir AA systems) is stuff they intended to replace in the future and already planned for CAPEX. Thus, if you would apply accounting terms that stuff is already depreciated to 0 even if still has some operational value.

The big question that we want answered is will be Russian forces insolvent? And they can be both financially and operationally insolvent. In the former they don't have cash to pay soldiers and suppliers and thus will have to depreciate their currency even further. In the latter they just don't have enough production capability and stock to cover the war needs for fuel, ammo and rations. Giving the know corruption on the military and government I think the latter is possible at least for a few critical items like MLRS ammo and cruise missiles.

Re:Research: ‘Ukraine war costs Russian military €20B per day’ by Martinussen on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:31AM (#30538972)
Those don't matter too much if you win first, I suppose.
Re:Research: ‘Ukraine war costs Russian military €20B per day’ by dragonwriter on Thursday March 03, 2022 @05:00AM (#30539146)
They do if you have other potential conflicts, of your choice or someone else’s, after winning.