The youngest you can sign up on Facebook is 14...how many 14 year olds are really going to care or know that maybe they should not let Facebook and every other 3rd party application know every nuance to how they use the internet?
Also by automatically having new privacy features opt-out, i'm sure they realize that if they lose 200k people because of it, it's nothing in the scheme of things. Plus chances are 100k of those people will end up reenabling their accounts at a later date.
(disclaimer: I work at FB, but not on this stuff.)
Maybe this is not generally a problem until you get software like Spotify (entirely third party) that now requires a Facebook account to work.
I don't know how they've pulled this off, whether they've forced non-Facebook accounts to add Facebook, or not. But if the former is the case, that is about as far from 'opt-in' as you can get. And up until an incomprehensible oversight was addressed (now 'cleverly' marketed as an amazing feature with its own name and everything), you couldn't opt out.
But of course that's not the end of it. Because the opt-in then opt-out model still allows Facebook to log even the most basic data from the user in that period of time in-between.
While Facebook's cavalier approach to privacy and ethics may become the examples that prove the importance of privacy and ethics in a transitional era (where the introduction of the internet into everyday life is still a very new concept), the "shoot first, ask questions later" method doesn't really endear them to anyone.
No business could show more contempt for its customers and for consumers by partnering up with a business like Facebook and demanding you sign up with them to subscribe to their service.
The percentage of people who are worried about privacy is smaller than you think, and those people are happy to use a smaller, worse login/checkout/whatever system if they get to keep their privacy.
If your feature is actually that helpful, then make it opt-in and promote the benefits to the user. If they "buy" it, they will use it. If they don't buy it, then you're doing something wrong anyway.
Companies, please stop eliminating my privacy by default when I use your service or product.