Re:The Fourth Quadrant: a Map of the Limits of Statistics (b...
by scott_s on Monday September 15, 2008 @10:10PM
(#305325)
I slogged through The Black Swan with the same attitude. He had some good insights, but he was so pompous I had difficulty following his reasoning. I'd continually get derailed when I encountered something that I thought was pure self-promotion.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Fourth Quadrant: a Map of the Limits of Statistics (b...
by Prrometheus on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @01:38AM
(#305474)
There is no greater crime in this country than creating something of value and being proud of it.
Other people often called "arrogant" - Paul Graham, Steve Jobs, etc.
Re:The Fourth Quadrant: a Map of the Limits of Statistics (b...
by scott_s on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @11:56AM
(#305871)
Be proud all you want. Just be able to explain your idea clearly. Taleb intersperses self-promotion in his explanations, which muddies them.
His writing style in general is meandering and lacks focus. The book I read had a handful of insights amid pointless narration. I read books like The Black Swan to learn new ideas, not to learn how great the author is.
Re:The Fourth Quadrant: a Map of the Limits of Statistics (b...
by 0x44 on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:53AM
(#305676)
Often it seems that people don't have a problem with the "arrogant" people themselves, but those who choose to surround them.
Re:The Fourth Quadrant: a Map of the Limits of Statistics (b...
by gz on Monday September 15, 2008 @10:30PM
(#305337)
Totally agree - pompous. That's the word I was looking for. The kind of author who creates a fictional character based 100% on himself, makes said character the intellectual and professional superior to his peers, the only one who survives the ups and downs of the market; and to top it all off names the character Nero! Seriously!
I found that "When Genius Failed" gives a great story-telling journalistic perspective on some of the same incidents Taleb talks about in his book while "The Drunkard's Walk" provides a good mathematical intuition (sans math sadly) behind seemingly rare events.