News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by greeneggs on Thursday September 29, 2011 @10:13AM (#3052474)
This would not work. Reviewers would not feel comfortable being completely honest if they knew their reviews would be published publicly. In any case, there should be no need for the reviews to be public.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by MikeTaylor on Thursday September 29, 2011 @06:33PM (#3054617)
Reviewers should be prepared to stand by their reviews. If they're not prepated for it to be known that they said something in a review, then they should not say that thing. Anonymity and secrecy in reviewing doesn't help the field.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by zbyszek on Thursday September 29, 2011 @12:00PM (#3052964)
Why should the reviewers feel unconfortable? In the current system, reviews are made available to the paper writers, and that doesn't seem to inhibit the reviewers, despite the fact that one often has a good idea of who the reviewers are, especially in the more niche fields of science.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by lutorm on Thursday September 29, 2011 @11:57AM (#3052949)
Even today reviewers run the risk of having their reviews made public, since nothing prevents the author from disseminating it. They are however normally anonymous.