Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open...
by omaranto on Thursday September 29, 2011 @09:51AM
(#3052409)
Do scientists put being a reviewer on their c.v.? I am under the impression that mathematicians don't, at least I don't remember seeing it done.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open...
by Jun8 on Thursday September 29, 2011 @10:20AM
(#3052495)
Most people in the EE and CS areas I have seen do. The reason is that they don't invite just anyone to do the reviewing, you have to be deemed knowledgeable in your field, so it signifies that.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open...
by jpdoctor on Thursday September 29, 2011 @11:05AM
(#3052711)
I always read it as: The candidate is well connected and has enough spare time to do reviews.
(FD: I've reviewed my share for IEEE. Now I have no time.)
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open...
by greeneggs on Thursday September 29, 2011 @10:17AM
(#3052488)
You can put it on your CV, although it is not important. Being a reviewer counts as "service" for your annual performance reviews, which is slightly more important. But most importantly, nobody wants to waste time reviewing mediocre papers. Everyone wants to review the best papers, from which they can learn the most while still fulfilling their reviewer duties.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open...
by jedbrown on Thursday September 29, 2011 @10:50AM
(#3052633)
Yes, unfortunately, it is almost more important to reject the bad papers. The good papers will be published regardless of the reviewer. It takes more work when I get a bad paper, especially when it comes from someone famous, because I have to make a convincing case for rejection. I've even gotten the same paper multiple times from different journals (after rejection an resubmission). It's hard work to prevent flawed science from being published.