News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by jbri on Thursday September 29, 2011 @06:05AM (#3051807)
No, everything PLoS ONE publishes is good because they reject everything that isn't good.

The "less selective" bit manifests itself as a reduced average "impact"/"importance", rather than as a reduced average quality.

Re:Academics should stop doing free peer-review for non-open... by MikeTaylor on Thursday September 29, 2011 @06:12AM (#3051829)
Exactly. Paradoxically, this policy has resulted in its getting a rather good impact factor for such a new journal (4.411 for 2010), which happily attracts more high-profile submissions in a virtuous circle.

The moral seems clear: other things being equal, freely accessible papers tend to get cited more often than paywalled ones. (Who would have guessed?)