Flagging certainly exists. What is your evidence in favor of censorship existing here?
If memory serves, there are website(s) that track which submission get flagged. If you’re concerned about a favored view or topic being flagged frequently, you could start there.
Otherwise you risk exerting lots of effort to simply find out that a favored view or topic isn’t shared by lots of people here. And, well, not all of them are equally important, or equally important to the HN audience.
HN has non-public mechanisms to detect some coordinated activity (e.g. upvoting submissions) across registered usernames.
> If there were organized efforts to censor specific topics
Note the "if" at the beginning of the sentence. It's not about transient topics, but long-term patterns. Broadly speaking, "censorship" is only one possible motive for coordinated activity, flagging or otherwise.
> If memory serves, there are website(s) that track which submission get flagged.
Thanks for the pointer, found https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29144989 & https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29113079 & https://github.com/MoserMichael/flagged-hn.
> The open data would tell an incomplete picture. It would still be an interesting to see what you can pull out, but you'd be guessing why a lot of the time.
The current implementation is like the DMCA. Anything can be censored for any reason without input from HN moderators. If the submitter is aware of the process, they can appeal to HN moderators. If HN readers saw the submission before it was flagged, they can also appeal to HN moderators.
If there were organized efforts to censor specific topics, one mitigation could be to deny the benefits of censorship. This could be done from public data by extracting a queue of flagged submissions and feeding them into another level of non-public analysis, automated + human. The surviving stories could then be posted to a dedicated site, e.g. using https://github.com/lobsters/lobsters.
If there were organized efforts to censor specific topics, a secondary public log of valid-but-censored articles could trigger the Streisand effect. Not only could this deny the benefit of censorship, it could cause censorship to have the opposite effect, reducing demand for organized flagging. This would have no impact on organic, non-coordinated flagging.