What does [flagged] mean?
Users flagged the post as breaking the guidelines or
otherwise not belonging on HN.
Moderators sometimes also add [flagged] (though not usually
on submissions), and sometimes turn flags off when they are
unfair.
A false positive is a user flag that was reversed on appeal, after manual review by HN human moderators.In a study, a list of false positive flags could be derived from public data.
In a study, additional false positive candidates could be identified after manual review.
It is very rare for those to be “deflagged.” Rare enough that there’s a moderation comment about turning flags off.
And an appeal that the community be on its better behavior. They are editorial exceptions not rule following corrections.
For the purpose of a study, gravity can be inferred from story rank.
> Sometimes, but only rarely, to the point of flagged-to-dead.
A study could examine the three categories of:
- gravity
- dead
- unfair
It would need to be long enough that all of those categories were non-zero.HN’s not a court of law.
In this sub-thread, "unfair" is quoted directly from the HN guidelines as the term for the objective event of a reversed flag, i.e. a "false positive", which we are discussing. It's not being used here as an adjective, it's being used to connect this discussion to the official HN FAQ.